I prefer both of the rooms and their owners to go away and never appear again.

I guess Paris hastily removed the mirrors from the ceiling prior to the photoshoot.

Black and white, loveit.

I'll take Paris's room, please. Nicky's room seems as vacant as her facial expressions.

"celebretards" rolls off better than "celebutards" i think.

anyway, i went with Paris's. and now i shall move away from this post and never look at it again. thank you.

Yuck - don't like either one!

neither of them. i would like it to be a combination of the two. the mirror bed, but black and white environment.

I like Nicky's. Clearly there are things I would change, but the pink room is too precious and floofy for me.

Also, they live in a hotel. I'd change that.

I am into the black and white room much more than the others.

Can we not use "retarded" as an insult? Not Nice, you know?

I'll take the b/w option, as much as I love pink, because that mirrored bed is TEH UGLY.

I pick Nicky's. It's a bit over the top with the patent, but I love it. I recall really liking it when it was showcased in InStyle a while back. I also love black and white, so that probably plays into it. I like Paris', but the pink would likely get on my nerves after a week.

I would take Nicky's cause that means her closet is attached.

i like nickys the best... i like the black/white. i'm not fond of that light peachy-pink color.

Both bedrooms scream "I'm a tackhead!"

Both give me anxiety. I would never be able to sleep in either, regardless of who owns them.

In my opinion, hejiranyc wins for comment of the post.

both are horrible. yes, and the rooms, too.

I am curious to know how many people would say they dislike both if we didn't know who they belong to. I like the black and white room much better. Pink is not my thing, especially the hideous powder pink of that room. But I do like the crisp black and white room. Especially the lamps.

UGH! this is like that game where you have to pick which is the least awful of two horrible options. Like being skinned alive or impaled. I'd choose the black & white option in this case.

Love B

I guess the black and white one... Except I hate the drapes and curtain rods. And I would repaint the walls and ceiling in a softer, less stark white... maybe grey. Then I'm set.

If I had to choose, then it would B.

Oddly enough, I prefer the Pink bedroom...
...if only it had green fretwork-patterned carpets and grasscloth wallpaper.

I'm always amazed at how boring the celebrity rooms we see on AT are. Both are okay as a base, but man, they need some personality. How about a few pieces of art? Something that doesn't slavishly adhere to the period? (Paris' bedroom needs a killer midcentury chandelier and a knockout piece of art. THEN it would look like something!!)

Look up Lance Armstrong's place. Or J-Lo's. Not a one of them has the slightest bit of personality!

Does Paris have a picture of herself on her nightstand????

Do we really have to choose...?

Neither.

And I decided that before I realized who they belong to. (Although that increases the 'ick' factor.)

Having said that, there are elements of the black/white room that I could like...but as is, they are both just too vacant and gaudy.

neither of the above. They're both hideous.

Neither. These are not pics I'd rip out and stick in my decor scrapbook.

neither! and that was decided before knowing the owners.

there are "celebrities" out there who really deserve to have their names in print, cant you highlight that type of celebrity on your site?

do we have to choose? fine, then I choose A.

But I won't ever admit it in public.

I would pick a hybrid of the two.

Neither one is really my thing, but if I had to choose I'd go with B, but I'd switch out the pink for an eggshell blue or pale mint green, and lose the chandelier. I kind of like that patent headboard in A, though.

nicky's. it would be even cooler if she had a black bourgie in it!

Ugh! Not a fan of either bedroom!

neither

Even before knowing whose they were, I didn't like either of them.

neither
both are so kitsch

Hate both of them!!

i really dont like either of the, too. im a guy so the pink one reminds me of my sisters room when she was 10 and the other one looks like a dominatrix room and thus doesnt look very relaxing.

Parts of both could be combined to make a decent room. I luff the mirror bed and the chandelier. The curtains are a bit frou-frou.

both are vile :)

Oh my god! I am a Paris!

Wow, this is such a respectable, professional post with eloquent vocabularly such as "celebutard" followed by the rash of comments scorning two perfectly fine rooms for biased reasons. The rooms may not be inspiring or perfect, but they are certainly lavish and coordinated. I doubt participants would pick them apart quite this critically if the rooms' inhabitants had remained anonymous. Casual blog or no, is this really necessary?
I'd like to thank the people that critiqued the rooms on the sole basis of their design, and I would like the author to rethink their use of words with hybrids of "retard" in them as a put-down in reference to people who do not have mental disabilities. Not only is it inaccurate, it's just plain tactless.
P.S. The "...depending on who you talk to," afterthought is just an insulting cop-out.

Nicky's room looks a little morbid with the black curtains. I like Paris', except for the over use of the color pink and the weird textile work on the curtains.

Nicky's is much better...

That pink monstrosity is made worse by the mirrored bed. So, so, so unexplainably ugly.

Ew. Not a fan of either, but if I had to chose, I'd definitely got with Nicky's room.

is it sad that i immediately recognized room B as belonging to paris hilton?

i think i prefer A, but even then i'd start changing around a lot of colors.

I like A a lot, actually. I would add some art and a bit of colour, perhaps make it more Anna Sui, but mmm I like it

B, even if my room is all pink, I do not like that particular shade, also it looks too cluttered

Both yucky!!!

Regardless of who the owners are, I'd pick none. They're really too blah for me. I guess they stripped the personality out of them to showcase them... jeje