We've been pretty smitten with our new laptop, but one thing we're always worried about is adding that first major scratch or ding on the casing. So we spent $55 and order the Zagg Invisible Shield to give us a bit of insurance against any minor blemishes after watching a few convincing videos about the protective nature of their electronics device skins...
The Zagg Invisible Shield kit comes with pre-cut pieces for the top, inside and bottom sections of the laptop, offering a wide selection of many models from various manufacturers. We laid the sheets ontop before removing the film to see how well cut they were and found an impressive quality in lining up with our MacBook Pro's form. A spray bottle, sparse instructions and a tiny rubber squeegee complete the installation kit.
The first section we attempted was the hardest: the inside near the trackpad. We made it a point to follow directions to a "T", as we've installed protective film on iPods, iPhones and smaller devices before and remember going slow and carefully is a necessity for a good finish. We had never attempted a larger surface, and this is where we ran into some serious trouble.
To be frank, the Zagg Invisible Shield is an extremely difficult application because of two reasons: 1) the larger surface area of these sheets make handling much more difficult than working with an iPhone sized skin, and 2) because of some aggressive adhesive, removing the larger sheets from their back causes slight and unavoidable stretching. This stretching basically ruined the fit for this inside sheet and after numerous attempts to try to make it fit, we realized we had one expensive piece of film that didn't fit the laptop correctly. So we removed it and moved on to the top panel.
The top panel sheet was easier to work with because it was one continuous rectangular sheet. Once again, the sizing prior to removal was perfect. And once again, removing the film from it's backing caused stretching because of the strong adhesive; whether we removed the sheet slowly or quickly, portions of the Zagg Invisible Shield wouldn't let go. We think this could be avoided if Zagg would pre-score sections of the sheeting for easier release. Carefully gently spraying the sheet on the front and back before application, we laid this top panel film onto our MacBook Pro with careful patience. But because of the slight stretching and perhaps also because of the MacBook Pro's curved corners, the film would not sit flush as hoped. The center and sides look beautiful, and the film is of high quality protection and feel. Sadly, those corner sections will undoubtedly mean the film will pick up dirt and eventually peel back over time.
Here you can see in the upper right hand corner a slight amount of the film lifting due to it's barely stretched state.
A close up of the other corner. We heeded the manufacturers recommendation to use a hair dryer on these corners, and although they would stay down initially, they'd lift up after a few minutes because of the slight stretch. We might try to carefully remove the excess later with an X-acto.
So for now, we've left just the top panel application, with plans to install the bottom later tonight when we don't have looming deadlines. We've already given the Zagg Invisible Shield a gentle scratch test, and as advertised, it does a great job of protecting the section it is covering. But we're hesitant to endorse a product whose installation process is inherently flawed, especially considering the price. The Zagg line of films might very well be an excellent investment for smaller devices, but we're hoping Zagg refines their laptop kits for easier handling and installation. In the meantime, we'll just stick to careful babying of our laptop, use our favourite sleeve, and just pray we don't scratch it any time soon.
Comments (11)
or you can just be ghetto like me and never take off the protective film that comes on the laptop.
With such a difficult application in the first place, why would anyone want to spend $55 to make their brand new aluminum MBP look like the shiny plastic macbooks of the past?
I've done my best to avoid them, but have a few scratches on the MBP that I've had for six months. To be honest, I'd rather have a few [barely noticeable] scratches on my precious laptop than have to stare at a peeling film...
santamonica: I certainly would not have spent the money if I knew it was such a chore, but that knowledge only came to me after the fact. The finish once applied is nice and not plasticky at all, more akin to dipped metal auto wheels. Noticeable scratches is such a subjective thing though; as someone who keeps his possessions in excellent condition, even a small scratch is not welcome and an eye sore. But if you're fine with small scratches, that's enviable...one less thing to worry about in life!
gregory - understandable, and thanks for previewing this product for everyone! I have to admit that I'm a bit of a hypocrite as I have a film on the screen of my iphone 3G; after waiting in line for HOURS for that thing, I wasn't going to give anything the opportunity to come in contact with it. The body of my laptop is something that I can apparently live with ;)
i have this on my blackberry. and honestly after the initial pain in my butt to install it, i love it. its been almost a year that i've had it on.
i've installed IS on nearly a dozen different ipods, phones, and my MBP. i agree with the comment that it makes the matte aluminum look like plastic. that's why i didn't install the top piece, only the bottom since that's what would get scratched the most. but i don't know how hard you guys were pulling to stretch the IS and ruin it. never had that happen before.
http://images36.fotki.com/v1181/photos/5/51621/396461/IMG_0698-vi.jpg
damn airport bins scratched my laptop when it was less than a week old. main reason i wanted to put IS on the bottom
http://images35.fotki.com/v1170/photos/5/51621/396461/IMG_0700-vi.jpg
Matt. M: the most stretching occurred on the piece that was to be installed on the interior surface around the trackpad, as it has cutout pieces that easily stretch compared to the large solid blocks of the bottom or top exterior pieces. Like I mentioned, installing these films aren't nearly as difficult on a small scale, but if you have a 15" wide sheet with a rectangle punched out in the middle, removing it and applying it become exponentially harder.
I wear the scratches with pride!
I have tried Zagg for both a Blackberry Pearl and my new iPhone. I had the shield on my Blackberry for quite some time with no problems. Eventually, the smaller cut pieces (around corners or buttons) would stretch and then collect dirt (after a year). The iPhone application was a complete disaster due to the same problem with the rounded corners. It just did not fit well in the corners, but looked perfect on the back and screen. I eventually removed it all when I won the Incase slide-on case from your site (which ROCKS by the way!)
Best Skins Ever makes a similar product. Same pros and cons as Invisible Shield.
http://www.bestskinsever.com/
I used the stuff on my white MacBook. It worked fine, but I spent 1/2 day with all kinds of soap, detergent, solvents, and scrubbers to get that stuff off when I wanted to sell the computer. Before you apply the IS, make sure you want it on forever.