apartment therapy changing the world, one room at a time


Barkeepers Friend: In the Test Lab

2-8-bkf.jpgProduct: Barkeepers Friend
Source: Local hardware store
Price: About $3
Rating: Strong Recommend*

Nutshell Review: One of the best cleaning products we've ever used, this non-toxic cleaner gets metal you think is beyond help back to its original shining state

Full Review: We can't remember where we first heard about Barkeepers Friend, but whoever it was, thank you from the bottom of our hearts. We admit that we're not the best day-to-day cleaners, instead preferring to do intense blitzes about once every two weeks. Unfortunately everything we own that's made of metal shows this.

 
 

While we never cared much about the bottom of our pots when we stashed them in cupboards, our current lack of kitchen cabinet space requires that all pots are hung on wall mounted peg board, turning their bottoms into part of the decor. And let's just say you couldn't tell that the bottoms of our hand-me-down Revereware were copper anymore. Barkeeper's Friend to the rescue. We simply rinsed the pot, used enough water to make the BKF into a paste, and let it sit for 5-10 minutes. A little scrubbing with a regular sponge later (and a rinse and repeat, because, hey, look at where we started) and wow, is that shiny or what? We've also used it on our stainless steel kitchen sink and our stainless pots and pans, with similar results. The best part? It's one of those old school naturally non-toxic products, a la Bon Ami.

2-8-copperpot.jpg it took two scrubbings, but look at that pot!

*Our Ratings:

  • Strong Recommend
  • Recommend
  • Weak Recommend
  • Don't Recommend

  • Tags

    Test Lab, cleaning, metal

    Related Links

    Share

    Comments (20)

    I started using Bar Keeper's friend when I got my first set of All-Clad, about nine years ago. It is THE BEST. We use it every time we cook in anything All-Clad -- insides, sides, bottoms and lids -- and my pots and pans look almost new. I remember when the big size cost 99 cents!

    posted by BB on 2008-02-08 17:22:43
    view BB's profile

    Thank you! My pots look like that--I needed to see the before and after to believe it--will buy some this weekend.

    posted by jen_g on 2008-02-08 17:24:21
    view jen_g's profile

    P.S. $6???? No way. Even Bed, Bath and Beyond sells it for $2.99.

    posted by BB on 2008-02-08 17:28:24
    view BB's profile

    I tried to use this for my enamel-coated vintage wedgewood stove, with not a ton of luck--does anyone have any ideas what I'm doing wrong or a product better suited to this?

    And BB--lucky people with cars can make it to a BB&B...the rest of us have to settle for neighborhood hardware stores (and markups)! :)

    posted by Shannon in SF on 2008-02-08 17:41:18
    view Shannon in SF's profile

    I use it for everything -- sinks, showers, taps, glass cooktop, and my All-Clad. The liquid version is awesome.

    The cheapest was to buy it is online - http://www.barkeepersfriend.com/

    posted by mschatelaine on 2008-02-08 17:46:16
    view mschatelaine's profile

    Shannon in SF: I wouldn't think you should use anything abrasive on enamel! You might try Simple Green ... use it straight (don't dilute).

    posted by Jane on 2008-02-08 17:57:20
    view Jane's profile

    I have an easier way to clean copper for you. Cut a lemon in half. Sprinkle salt on the copper, scrub with the lemon half. The grime comes right off. And if you don't have the lemon and salt, just squirt some ketchup on and wipe off. For really dirty pot bottoms, you might need to use just a bit of elbow grease, but really, either solution works amazingly well and quickly.

    posted by greer on 2008-02-08 18:14:26
    view greer's profile

    It's worked great for everything I've used it with, even gets the scratches on my porcelain sink!

    posted by Ana on 2008-02-08 18:32:24
    view Ana's profile

    wow! I had no idea it was considered environmentally safe. I love this stuff but I always reserved it as a last resort because I thought it was toxic... now I can clean with wild abandon!

    posted by Button on 2008-02-08 19:24:07
    view Button's profile

    Love this stuff but the powder form has an unpleasant scent. The liquid doesn't, though.

    posted by Lesley on 2008-02-08 19:26:31
    view Lesley's profile

    I love this stuff, but I'd recommend wearing gloves while using it. I went crazy cleaning with this after I saw the magic it worked on my water-stained stainless steel silverware, but the next day the top layer of skin on my hands peeled off.

    posted by AlisonM on 2008-02-08 20:43:12
    view AlisonM's profile

    I use it on all of my pots and pans. It works miracles for hard water stains and strange tub marks. I got multiple friends, my mother and my sister using it. Plus my local grocery store sells it for only $1.49 (yay Kroger). Bon Ami also works very similarly for the same cost.

    posted by Signe on 2008-02-08 21:49:52
    view Signe's profile

    i've got a can of this, but i don't use it much since i found out about mr.clean erasers. it will clean the same pot bottom with only water hardly any scrubbing. try it, you'll love it!

    posted by mod*mom on 2008-02-09 02:15:27
    view mod*mom's profile

    greer, you beat me to it! I just finished giving some big copper bowls the lemon & salt treatment. No elbow grease required.

    When the pots were shiny I dropped the used lemon in the disposal for a little air freshener.

    I suggest using gloves if the copper is really tarnished. When the tarnish comes off it can stain your finger nails a gross dark green color.

    posted by Slim on 2008-02-09 02:30:38
    view Slim's profile

    mod*mom --

    Mr. Clean erasers contain carcinogenic compounds, and are very toxic. BKF is very safe.

    posted by mschatelaine on 2008-02-09 08:14:54
    view mschatelaine's profile

    ...shouldn't say "very toxic", but the Mr.Clean erasers contain Formaldehyde-Melamine-Sodium bisulfite copolymer. Formaldehyde is a carcinogen (there are many sources for it in homes), and given that there have been no studies on the effects of exposure to cleaning products, beauty products etc., which contain this and other suspect chemicals, it may be a good idea to limit exposure where possible. Afterall, that whole pet food scare last year demonstrated that you do not need to have toxic chemicals to produce serious health consequences.

    posted by mschatelaine on 2008-02-09 13:16:56
    view mschatelaine's profile

    This stuff really is awesome, although I agree with the comment above that you should wear gloves when using it. I use it on stainless steel All-Clad pans and have used it to get the rust and black stuff off really old copper hardware (doorknobs, etc.)

    posted by Jenny in DC on 2008-02-09 14:04:40
    view Jenny in DC's profile

    Doesn't BKF have Oxalic Acid in it? Bon Ami is marble dust which isn't toxic compared to BKF. I have both, but be careful with acids.

    posted by kaanswfm on 2008-02-10 15:39:07
    view kaanswfm's profile

    ketchup also brings dirty copper back to its shiny state.

    posted by colellis on 2008-02-11 14:51:29
    view colellis's profile

    This was an aptly timed article! I recently burned my tea kettle and I was resiting using BKF to clean it. I eventually gave in, because I didn't want to get rid of my kettle. After cleaning it I saw this post and now I don't feel so bad! In fact I am heading off to buy a new can of BKF soon!

    Tea Kettle Dilemma

    posted by Green Me on 2008-02-20 11:34:46
    view Green Me's profile