apartment therapy changing the world, one room at a time


Good Questions: Where are these houses?

2006_08_17_rowhouses.jpg

Does anyone know where this row of colourful houses is?

- Peter

Note: Include a pic of your problem and your question gets posted first.
Email questions & pics with QUESTIONS in subject line to: sf(at)apartmenttherapy(dot)com
Link To All Good Questions
 
 

Peter, We don't! But we're also curious. Was this too-perfect SF scene location-scouted or tarted up just for the advertisement?

Anyone have the story?


Tags

Good Questions

Related Links

Share

Comments (16)

My guess is that it can be found in Photoshop.....

posted by Katie on 2006-08-18 14:02:36

It looks tarted to me...

posted by MyNameisEarlGrey on 2006-08-18 14:02:47

Yeah... it looks like the land of Photoshop.

posted by RP on 2006-08-18 14:06:55

Surely that's a single townhouse duplicated at different angles, then colorized.

posted by wende in san francisco on 2006-08-18 14:08:53

tarted up indeed! harlot!

posted by victoria on 2006-08-18 14:10:41

i agree with everyone else about the fakery, but the "inspiration" could come from a row of about 3 houses that look very much like those on central between haight and page.

posted by carole on 2006-08-18 14:18:15

I thought, too, of the ones on Central. I have always admired them.

posted by Lesley on 2006-08-18 14:27:43

I write from the land of car industry- photography and agencies [in LA ] and would bet my last dollar it doesn't exsist...we do crap like that all the time in my similar field.

On occasion, the car never even went to the actual location... it's stripped in at post-prodt.

posted by -anon on 2006-08-18 15:22:59

its photoshopped, but it *should* be in the Castro.

posted by catherine on 2006-08-18 16:10:17

look, the curtian even hangs the exact same way in all three windows. I would say that this was probably made in a 3D modeling program. Personally, I think I'd go with the pink house, no maybe the blue one...

posted by Jessi on 2006-08-18 16:44:26

For myself, I want the yellow one or the orange one. They all remind me of sno-cones for some reason, but in a good way.

I'd love to live on a block like that.

posted by Josie on 2006-08-18 16:50:25

It's definitely not a real street and I'm sure that it's not cgi 3d models (my line of work) because the perspective wouldn't be messed up the way it is if either were the case. I'd bet good money that it's created with one of two ways:
1) using two photos of the same house
2) using single photos of two different, but very similar houses.

Barring color, the left three are the same house (same angle, same mouldings, same highlights and reflections) and the the right three are the same house (the artist changed the middle windowshade in the orange house to make it less repetitive but it's still the same everything else). If it weren't for the missing moulding above the second floor bay of the three left houses, I'd say all six were definitely the same building.

The car is unquestionably comped in since it's being lit from the right while the houses are lit from the left. The faked reflections of the houses on the wet street is a nice touch to bring it altogher, though. Props to the ad artist.

posted by harlie on 2006-08-18 17:26:33

Well to beat a dying topic, its photoshop, 2 houses, left three are the same, right three are the same. You can tell in the mouldings, window sizes, and the highlights from the sun, and also noticed the far left tree, how its foilage is cut harshly off where the blue house was dropped in. As harlie noted they did change the windowshade in the orange house to break up such an obvious pattern, but patterns still exist in the highlights, in a true to life shot done with a real row of houses such as in the image the highlights wouldn't fall on each house in the same spots....anyways...blah. Nice work though

posted by kmduke on 2006-08-18 22:47:32

I agree, fake. It sure is pretty though. Does anyone else notice the second story windows on the 3 left side houses? They're all grey. It makes those windows look odd. But that plus the way all the curtains in the right 3 houses are placed the same, kinda gives it away that it's fake.

posted by cassandra from canada on 2006-08-21 10:29:15

it's photoshop. you can tell. for one, the colors aren't natural for outdoor light. for another, look at the blinds in the windows. a few of them are exactly the same. you can tell it's just cloned.

posted by mg on 2006-08-21 19:19:45

houses dont line up properly.

cloned tree - layer messed up frame left where blue house is over the cloned tree.

random bit of roof inbetween green house and yellow house?

still a good pic tho.

posted by dz on 2006-08-22 19:14:33