apartment therapy changing the world, one room at a time


Dishware: All White or a Mix?

042009 dishware.jpgThere are a lot of reasons to choose white dinnerware - the emphasis remains on the food, pieces are easy to replace - but for some, standard white can be a bit boring...

 
 

042009 dishware 2.jpgWhile we stick mainly with white for our dishware, we do like mixing in a few colorful pieces (like these bowls or these mugs), as well. A rainbow of colorful dishes can look really vibrant and cheerful (above), though too much variety in the styles of dishware can just as easily start to look cluttered. So which do you prefer? All white, a mix, a particular pattern or just whatever the heck you can find? Let us know.

Images: Top is Martha Stewart's Kitchen, above is from Chris and Stephanie's Hip Lower Haight Home

Tags

Kitchen, tabletop & servingware, Dining Room

Related Links

Share

Comments (39)

My every day dishes are Homer Laughlin green stripe restaurantware. Sturdy, steady, dependable and an appropriate palate for serving my main fare: blue collar comfort food.

For non-everyday, I choose white pottery for entertaining as a base. Table linens, flatware, glasses. salad plates, dessert plates and other accoutrement work to change up the basic mood or seasonal vibe. In that respect, the white pottery is an ideal foundation for any table. It certainly doesn't compete with the food. Ultimately, I want my food to dominate the tablescape and the whiteware is the ideal frame.

posted by ShellyinMSP on April 20th 2009 at 7:53pm
view ShellyinMSP's profile

Even though I love color and texture on a table, from a practical perspective, I think that white should be the basis of a dishware collection with special colored pieces mixed in. My go to set is Elements at Crate and Barrel (though I'm not crazy about the mugs.) It begins at $1.95 http://www.crateandbarrel.com/family.aspx?c=4310&f=1666&q=elements&fromLocation=Search&DIMID=400001&SearchPage=1

----
Personal reflections on sophisticated design for $1K or less: www.onegrandhome.com

posted by 1GH on April 20th 2009 at 8:07pm
view 1GH's profile

C'mon, I collect vintage Fiesta, Riviera, and Harlequin. All white? Boring!

p.s. Love the Russell Wright picture. Is that American Modern?

posted by quiltmaster on April 20th 2009 at 8:13pm
view quiltmaster's profile

Our everyday dishes are Fiesta--colbalt and white. I have obsessed over the cobalt since I was ten, but I added the white as my husband wanted white plates.

For our "fancy" china, they are all white (Madison from Crate & Barrel), but we included gorgeous pieces from other lines that we loved but didn't like the full pattern. To be honest, I think that the matchy-matchy china thing is so dated--to me, it's a little futzy. I'd rather have simple dishes that don't overwhelm the food that is resting on them.

posted by Elizabeth @ Take Back Your Kitchen on April 20th 2009 at 8:19pm
view Elizabeth @ Take Back Your Kitchen's profile

I have a set of 8 of Wedgwood Queen's Ware, the plain, cream-colored style. I'd like to get some other plates and colored glassware to add accents. Goes with everything, though, and can be dressed up and dressed down.

Although I only own a couple of bowls (which I use for my dogs food and water), I think Fiestaware is fantastic.

posted by ilima on April 20th 2009 at 8:21pm
view ilima's profile

Plain white, because I love how most of the foods I make look great on white, then I add color with salad or dessert plates - charger plates - linens - flowers. I have so many different salad/dessert plates that I'm afraid to count them all...

posted by Rucy on April 20th 2009 at 8:37pm
view Rucy's profile

Most of my dishes are Wachtersbach red. I have a bright and lively base, and the style is basic enough, I can mix in accents of white or bright as the crush strikes me.

posted by EconGrrl on April 20th 2009 at 8:38pm
view EconGrrl's profile

We kept everything white and decorate with placemats, centerpieces, napkins etc. I just think white is more versatile and allow me infinite creativity without buying a ton of different dishes. I do like the idea of mixing patterns or brightly colored solids with white dishes though.

posted by http://modernquiltlove.wordpress.com on April 20th 2009 at 9:02pm
view http://modernquiltlove.wordpress.com's profile

I have a mini set of Russel Wright's white dishes that I use for holiday meals since the plates are the biggest I have. But for everyday use, I have Fiestaware in many colors.

posted by palindrome on April 20th 2009 at 9:11pm
view palindrome's profile

Multi-colored Fiestaware...though the brightest (red, chartreuse) are hidden away because I have a housemate who's allergic to bright colors (also because we have too many dishes between the four of us).

posted by thursday on April 20th 2009 at 9:25pm
view thursday's profile

My plates are cobalt blue, which actually looks great with all types of food.

posted by Sassy in SF on April 20th 2009 at 9:34pm
view Sassy in SF's profile

White.....but I let myself collect salad/dessert plates in whatever color or pattern I want.

They're great for a cheerful small breakfast or dessert.

Chocolate cake is fun on a pink polka-dotted plate.

posted by ohjodi on April 20th 2009 at 9:57pm
view ohjodi's profile

Pfaltzgraff Seychelles "Blue Lagoon". I think there was a post on kitchn that discussed food photography on blue plates and whether or not it was appetizing. I think it's lovely and makes me want to eat my food slowly, which is healthier!

posted by clampers on April 20th 2009 at 10:11pm
view clampers's profile

i don't remember the brand but ours are from Macys. A combination of light green and white.

The plates are square with a rounded corner. White salad plates, green dinner plates, green bowls, and green mugs. Then white dipping bowls and some larger serving bowls. I had it all laid out in the store as if it was a table to find the most appealing combo.

Then after all that it went on sale for more off, and i brought the receipt in and adjusted it all. The woman helping me was really nice, since I ddi buy a ton of stuff. However, very worth it, i ended up buying some spares of certain things (helpful since my wife has broken a few plates and bowls now) and ended up saving around $150 on all of it. Worth 20 minutes to me...

posted by jmorey on April 20th 2009 at 10:11pm
view jmorey's profile

I used to have all black stoneware- functional and chip-proof, but so boring. I've started collecting each type of dish from a different set. Now I've got blue, grey, and white and it works perfectly.

posted by poissondujour on April 21st 2009 at 1:00am
view poissondujour's profile

I can't decide!

posted by deepa on April 21st 2009 at 1:43am
view deepa's profile

I have a lot of white pieces- dinner plates, small bowls, appetizer plates, ramekins, and two smaller serving bowls and then I have muted teal coffee mugs, dessert plates, large serving bowls, and a platter.

posted by Cheryl K on April 21st 2009 at 7:08am
view Cheryl K's profile

Unless plain white is really high-quality, it has a first-year-out-of-school look. It's the futon of dinnerware.

posted by Lisa (Montreal) on April 21st 2009 at 7:44am
view Lisa (Montreal)'s profile

Once upon a time, I had only mismatched everything, dishes, glasses, utensils, sheets, towels. I found the first time I bought a set of matching sheets that it was somehow calming, no having to make choices or judge if the patterns were working together every time I looked at them.

Nowadays, I've got some sets of things that match and some that are disparate...its good to have options, good to have a balance.

posted by kristen verity on April 21st 2009 at 8:02am
view kristen verity's profile

i like a mixture of similar/complementary colors and patterns. i don't mind mismatched stuff if there's a common design thread -- in fact, i prefer that to all matchy matchy.

posted by abigailbelle on April 21st 2009 at 8:33am
view abigailbelle's profile

For all you people who like Fiestaware, you should check out Bauer ware, the original. It's more expensive (vintage, collectible, esp in the CA area), but waaaay more interesting looking.
Our everyday dishes are Crate and Barrel Nuit - we picked them AFTER we'd put together a pretty big collection of handmade pottery of all types and colors, because it anchors the handmade stuff, goes with everything, and is easily replaceable. Also dishwasher safe, which the handmade stuff is not.
I'd like to put in a plug for all the potters out there - find out if your area has a guild, or potters' organization. In central NJ, the Potters' Guild of NJ has at least 2 sales a year, sometimes more. It's a great way to support local craftspeople and add some real character to your home.

posted by Texaninexile on April 21st 2009 at 9:12am
view Texaninexile's profile

All my dinner plates are from different places (IKEA, Habitat, my Mum) but they're all white with blue pattern on them. I didn't start off intending for this to happen, I just love the combination! Stacking isn't a problem as dinner plates are all roughly the same size. My smaller (cake/breakfast) plates are mismatched. I don't really care as long as I like each individual piece.

posted by Sian on April 21st 2009 at 10:37am
view Sian's profile

My everyday and "fancy" is the same - my grandmother's Crown Ducal transferware in Pink. It's a pretty exuberant toile pattern, and I love it. I added in some plain pink Fire King bowls because the shape of the Crown Ducal bowls wasn't great for pasta (which I make a lot of). No white for me!

posted by el326 on April 21st 2009 at 11:17am
view el326's profile

Most of my dishes are all white and I like the clean crisp look of them.

posted by suzy8track on April 21st 2009 at 12:55pm
view suzy8track's profile

poissondujour... we have all black Thai stoneware and have to disagree-- we LOVE it. It has a similar effect to white in terms of being a blank canvas and making food look great (vegetables pop particularly well) and we have such a variety of shapes that we don't get bored. it's all been collected from thrift stores over the years so it was cheap too! it looks fantastic against crisp white linens, as well as with colors.

that said... i also have a full set of mismatched blue & white vintage ironstone (blue willow, etc.), which tends to make an appearance at breakfast and in the summer. and a full dessert/luncheon set of mixed Coalport from the late 1800's in rose pink and gold... and a luncheon set on 1920s-60's marigold yellow & gold mixed bone china... both fun for being fancy, and also just beautiful to look at.

clearly, i have a dish addiction. on the bright side, i cook/entertain constantly! so they do get used. =)

posted by marie516 on April 21st 2009 at 1:10pm
view marie516's profile

I recently got rid of some dishes I'd grown tired of (basic blue/green stuff) and some square red dishes that were not all that practical (2 place settings) and replaced it w/ some Asian inspired red dinner ware from Gibson that I love. Red interiors w/ matte onyx on the outside. My flatware is the POEM from IKEA.

For collecting, Russel Wright's American Modern or Iriqouis or better yet, the Franciscan Starburst patter for fun, and w/ the RW stuff, I'd mix the colors w/ in the pattern so it's not all one color.

Harkerware makes a set I'd like, pastel interiors w/ light gray exteriors, don't know the pattern and I have a few serving pieces of that and would love the small sauce bowls to use as candle holders for liquid candles as a table centerpiece in several colors (pink, yellow and blue).

I find all white to be BORING

posted by ciddyguy on April 21st 2009 at 1:19pm
view ciddyguy's profile

I find all white to be LOVELY. All of my dishes are white, and my cupboards look great. None of my dishes are from the same line, the dinner plates are white ones that I liked, the salad plates are a different shape/texture (but still white), The pasta dishes are different ... you get the picture.

The keys to making a monochromatic palette work, are shape and texture.

posted by JulieLeanne on April 21st 2009 at 3:16pm
view JulieLeanne's profile

I have Colourglaze crockery, which is a 1950s/60s line released by Crown Lynn - a New Zealand pottery manufacturer. These are examples - some of my coffee cups. They're a lovely jumble of pretty colours, but the shape of the plates is very simple and streamlined so I enjoy the look. I've recently added a few vintage Poole plates to my collection, and they're a soft off-white but a very similar shape. I love the look of my cupboards, especially as they're a dark slate gray so the colours really pop.

posted by nessaneko on April 21st 2009 at 9:18pm
view nessaneko's profile

I have vintage Stetson salad plate/bowls that have 4 MCM leaves painted on each one in 4 different colors (robin's egg blue, lime green, pale pink, and a gray/taupe color). I have very small bowl/plate items that match (for dessert/bread and butter/side dishes...I don't know).

To complement these colors I have vintage robin's egg blue plates with gray/taupe undersides, lime green ikea bowls, and vintage pink-stripes glasses. I love the way they all coordinate but don't match.

By the way, I can't post comments when I'm using safari, is there anything that can be done about this?

posted by zhasmene on April 21st 2009 at 10:57pm
view zhasmene's profile

What's with the giant collection of egg cups in the first photo? And everything else, I guess, but I'm most impressed by the egg cups.

Oh, and we use white china with bright floral accents (C&B's anna's artistry, for what it matters). It looks lovely for everyday and for entertaining.

posted by karenenen on April 22nd 2009 at 7:35am
view karenenen's profile

all white = incredibly boring

I actually don't own ANY white dishes. I love warm, bold colors so my dishes are goldenrod yellow, deep red, bright green, blue etc. Nothing matches, but they all go together gorgeously.

I also collect jadite and vintage pyrex so the more colors the better!

posted by geekgirl on April 22nd 2009 at 7:38am
view geekgirl's profile

I have Denby Imperial Blue dishes. They're blue on the outside and rims, with a touch of brown at the edges of the rims, with white centers. So it's white where the food sits, but you have blue accents. I *love* them. Some of the serving pieces are all blue and some are like the dishes (blue exterior with white interior). They're casual enough for every day (and I do use them every day), but easy to dress up as well for something more fancy.

I also have my grandmother's china. It's more of an eggshell or off white color, with a lovely pastel floral pattern. Admittedly I don't use it much.

posted by Shana Lee on April 22nd 2009 at 7:56am
view Shana Lee's profile

I am so bad when it comes to collecting china! It is EVERYWHERE in my house, but I love the flexibility to create a table that is unique every time--even for day-to-day use. I actually coordinate the food and the plates, although I am not sure my boyfriend has figured this out yet fully. I even do it for a simple lunch. Here are my additions, errr COLLECTIONS:

Blue Ridge: All yellow floral without a border; Chintz; Carol's Roses;Poinsettia (I have been collecting BR since I was a child...a favourite memory with my Mother.)
Paden City: Shenandoah Pastels, Burgundy, Chartreuse (which looks amazing all the time, but especially with Asian or Mexican foods.); Forrest Green (These last three work well with the BR Poinsettia at Christmas.)
Vernon Kilns: Native California
Misc: White square plates and platters from Target and Sur la Table; huge white mugs from Crate & Barrel; lots of red and red/orange Wachtersbach; some Fiesta in vintage green and yellow; some Russell Wright and old Finnish glass bowls from my Grandmother.

I recently held a little dinner party and used a bright pink and red check table cloth, vintage rose embroidered linen napkins with green stitching, white Target plates and only the mint green serving bowls and salad plates from my Vernon Kilns collection. It was modern and sleek, and at the same time had two splashes of vintage. (I also made the Chicken In Milk with Lemon raved about by Faith on here.) I love the creativity of having so many choices!

posted by Shabbydiva on April 22nd 2009 at 8:25am
view Shabbydiva's profile

I'm just now clearing cupboards doing the Kitchn Cure, and I'm not happy with my dinnerware and flatware. However, I've never really given a thought to it, honestly. We have a very small kitchen with limited storage, so a set of everyday plus a set of fancy is out--I'm shooting for good mid-range stuff that goes happily in the dishwasher but looks/feels decent for a dinner party. We have a bright red table, so I was going for all-white, but it's all leaving me kind of cold. It's helpful to read all your opinions for the simple reason that for once in my life I have no opinion of my own! Dishes. Who cares? Oh yeah I guess I gotta decide on some dishes... And suddenly it matters.

posted by cmcinnyc on April 22nd 2009 at 9:44am
view cmcinnyc's profile

1950s design classic Teema from Iittala. White except for the turquoise breakfast/apetizer plates and some striped cereal bowls from the coordinating series Origo, in a colour combination that has sadly been discontinued.

Teema
http://www.iittala.com/web/Iittalaweb.nsf/en/products_eating_dinnerware_teema

Origo
http://www.iittala.com/web/Iittalaweb.nsf/en/products_eating_dinnerware_origo

posted by katti on April 22nd 2009 at 9:59am
view katti's profile

I'm a dishware whore, if you will. I scour thrift stores every two weeks or so to find beautiful plates, mugs, teacups...I love them all! I also have a set of Ikea dishes, but I've been pretty disappointed with them--they crack so easily!

Some of my best finds are:

-a set of 10 saucers and small mugs from Wellesley Royal USA - the pattern that I looked up for the dinner plates was pretty obnoxious, but the cups and saucers are just adorable! And when you have lots of dinner parties, they're perfect for coffee or hot chocolate ($10 for all)

-three 60s green goblets ($1.50)

-vintage Christmas plate for cookies ($1)

-beautiful swirly glass platter and dessert plates ($4)

None of them really match, but I'm trying to work out vingettes that work together to put into some sort of storage unit.

posted by amidalailama on April 22nd 2009 at 7:47pm
view amidalailama's profile

I tend to buy small sets (4 place settings each) of various patterns. I try to think about whether the pattern I want to pick up could be mixed attractively with any of my other sets if I needed additional place settings for a dinner party. This way I have something vaguely cohesive if needed, but don't feel stuck with one set or plain white.

posted by bonjourmiette on April 22nd 2009 at 8:18pm
view bonjourmiette's profile

i have new (not antique) fiestaware in every color. i do not have any of the new chocolate yet or the new green! can't wait to find some.

posted by sunnyvolvo on April 24th 2009 at 2:56pm
view sunnyvolvo's profile

I have yellow Teema plates, and I love them. They look farmhouse-y to me, and food looks good on them. As a rule I don't like white crockery, although cream is ok.

posted by RubyB on April 29th 2009 at 4:29am
view RubyB's profile