When faced with the choice, however, A Fresh Squeeze also offers up analytical reasons on why plastic might actually be better than paper (or vice versa, depending on your habits thereafter); read all about it here. And not ones to just toot their own horn and push their own products, the Squeeze team also links us over to an entire site devoted to reusable bags (some favorites below).
Cotton canvas messenger shopping bag ($12.95)
Gecko Traders recycled wave tote ($35.95)
(Thanks, A Fresh Squeeze!)