For a while we were obsessed with Lush soaps and bath bombs. Our passion has cooled, but we still like their products, which are hand-made and fresh (marked with expiration dates). After testing, we found that some natural ingredients (like oatmeal scrubs) ended up clogging our drain, while others smelled great and worked wonders.
We like the fact that packaging for soaps and bars is minimal, and we highly recommend the aptly named Therapy Massage Bar. If you're into baths, we suggest the Sex Bomb (shown) and Butterball Bath Ballistics.