Name: Susan MacTavish Best
Location: Pacific Heights, San Francisco, California
Size: 3,000 square feet
Years lived in: 2; rented
Stepping inside Susan's home is a feast for all of the senses. From the front entry to the backyard, every square inch of her space tells a story, while the delicious aromas of a cooking experiment waft from the kitchen. Susan is an entertainer extraordinaire. She's an expert at bringing together an eclectic mix of people over delicious food, fancy cocktails, and live entertainment, all within a soothing, yet tantalizing environment.
The first time I visited Susan's house it was an unseasonably warm evening in San Francisco. She welcomed me with a gin and tonic, made with a squeeze of fresh orange. Time seems to stand still once you enter her home, and there is never a dull moment, what with all of the cooking activity and visual stimulation. As we stood around the kitchen munching on delectable bites of marinated goat cheese drizzled over crostini, I thought, now this is living. If the food and cocktails aren't reason enough to pop in for one of Susan's parties, the lively conversation and talented musical performances held in her living room provide extra incentive.
As the founder and author of the blog Living MacTavish, Susan writes about everything from food, to fashion, to design and entertaining. She's worldly, well-traveled and the sort of person you could never be bored standing next to. Every piece of furniture, each trinket, photo and work of art in her home is a story waiting to be told. Her space embodies a respect for history, an appreciation for innovation, and a love for good design. It's a gallery of her treasures that appears chaotic, yet intentional. Each room is a new adventure, and Susan herself is the personification of the warm, fun, and unconventional spirit her house exudes.
Apartment Therapy Survey:
My Style: My style is to mix up pieces from different centuries and put them next to each other so that the eye is never bored. I might put an Audobon print next to a Calder litho in a room that has furniture from the 1790s and 1960s all on a sheepskin-fur covered floor. Think Royal Tenenbaums in a Scottish country pile with a nod to Silicon Valley.
Inspiration: I cook all the time (I'm working on a cookbook so I have many recipes to test), and entertain friends a few times a week. I've always tried to create a home that makes people want to walk in the front door, that makes them feel at ease and stay a while. I like bringing together eclectic folks who might not know each other otherwise, and encouraging them to meet and talk and be themselves minus airs and graces. Having a home that is inviting makes people far more at ease.
I grew up in Scotland in an old Georgian building in the country, built by Robert Adam. It had massive rooms, yet each room was cosy and inviting and filled with antiques, books and curiosities. That's my inspiration, to recreate that feeling where you want to sit down for a while, and you're never bored.
Favorite Element: My upstairs bathroom is long, very white and has high ceilings. I use it as a gallery (and a bathroom!).
Biggest Challenge: Ostensibly this house is a small Victorian which has lots of little rooms. The rooms have a tendency to feel cramped. I prefer big open spaces myself. The bonus is that you can make each room feel like another scene. The bedrooms in the house are small and dark. I decided to paint my master bedroom deep, war brown, and make it a very welcoming refuge to unwind rather than fight the natural darkness of the room.
What Friends Say: Comfortable, cosy, homey, so much to look at, it's like a gallery. They also tend to say it smells really good, as I'm usually at work in the kitchen. Good food and comfortable places to sit equal very content friends!
Biggest Embarrassment: One of my favorite restaurants in San Francisco is SPQR. They've done a fantastic job of keeping the restaurant both open and warm. I noticed they painted their ceiling a deep purple. I tried to copy them and paint my dining room ceiling a deep purple too, but it turned out to be a rather violent purple. Fortunately, my guests are too preoccupied with each other and the food to look up.
Proudest DIY: I hung all of the art by myself in one evening. I love hanging paintings. I like to think about where I'm going to hang art while I'm running. It's a fun puzzle.
Biggest Indulgence: When I was nine, my mother took me to Galerie Maeght in Paris. They were having a show of Walasse Ting and I promised myself that one day I would own one of his works. I've since collected three of them. They are so cheery, and I love his work now just as much as when I was nine.
Best Advice: Create a home that you love coming back to at the end of the day. It is, after all, your home. You should feel entirely yourself in it.
Dream Sources: I subscribe to foreign design magazines. Any auction catalogue (Sothebys, Christies, Bonhams), Marie Claire Idees, Vogue Living Australia, Maison Francaise.
Resources of Note:
ENTRY
- • My hallway is very wide. I treat it as an extension of my living room. I have a wide leather couch from Restoration Hardware that I always flop down on when I come home.
• Pablo Light: San Francisco Light Designer.
• Mirrors: bought at a Bonhams auction. They open up the hallway, making it much brighter and seemingly larger, and let you glimpse art in the living room. You can find these at estate auctions. I like that they are mismatched.
• Walt Disney original cartoon from my mom on my third birthday. My mom gave me a piece of art for my birthday every year growing up, which was such a fantastic tradition. I was allowed to sell them when I turned 21 but of course I never have sold any of the pieces.
• The WASP cartoon: I have a blog called What Would A Wasp Do and so I love this.
LIVING ROOM
- • Sheepskin Rugs: Lawson Farms
• French portrait: late 1700's from auction at Bonhams.
• Chaise: Restoration Hardware
• Books: They make every room cosier and I think are such an extension of ourselves. I suspect as more and more people read digital texts, books will become seen more as art.
• Sheep's Head: Chelsea Antiques in Petaluma, on Main Street
• Kidney shaped table by Adrian Pearsall: Inherited from my grandmother. You can find them on 1stDibs.
• Plastic rocking chair: Kartell
• Portrait of my grandmother. On my to-do list is to get a portrait done by Kimberly Brooks, a super talented portrait painter based out of LA. (She's also the founder of the arts section on HuffPo, and the wife of Albert Brooks).
• Stool my friend made with logo on it. He started a company called Spoonflower that prints fabric and wallpaper on demand.
DINING ROOM
- • Light: Chelsea Antiques in Petaluma
• Pheasants: Given to me by the owner of Period George, my favorite store! (the art of dining).
• Big, massive silver spoon: Period George. There was a second one at Period George that Thomas Keller bought.
• Danese Milano jigsaw puzzle of animals: I've had this since I was a baby.
• Spode Blue Clipper China. I grew up with this. (easy to buy online anywhere). They appear to have stopped Blue Clipper but I'd go to Gumps to buy china, such a fantastic selection.
KITCHEN
- • Blackboard for menus: Billyboards
• Labels for all my food: Designed by Gershoni
• Old clock I've had since I was 3, so retro!: 1stdibs
• My craigslist TV poster. I work with craigslist so it makes me happy to see the poster and the stories that have come out of that project.
• All my photos of my friends. I use smugmug to store and print them.
• Cookbooks: I use old dated cookbooks for inspiration. Your local library will probably have a sale at least once a year and that's a good place to find them.
BEDROOM
- • California King bed (I'm tall and it's very high up so dogs can't
jump up!): Restoration Hardware
• Painting by my grandfather. He was born in Northern Maine but spent his life mostly in Toronto. This painting looks like Maine!
• Painting by his son, my father. My father died when I was very young so I really treasure this and like to see it when I wake up in the morning.
• Poems by my maternal great grandmother that are framed.
• Audobon print: Arader Galleries.
• Skull: Bonhams has occasional Natural History auctions and this is where I found the skull.
• Cream velvet curtains: Pottery Barn
• Light by Pablo
BATHROOM
- • School photos from sleepaway school at St. Leonards in Scotland and from uni at Oxford. People often think I've bought them, they don't realize I'm actually in them!
• Guest book: Papersource. I love reading the comments from the guest book after a party.
• Lollipops: Tootsie roll lollipops are very popular when I leave them in a bowl in the bathroom.
Thanks, Susan!
(Images: Lindsay Tella)
• HOUSE TOUR ARCHIVE Check out past house tours here
• Interested in sharing your home with Apartment Therapy? Contact the editors through our House Tour Submission Form.
• Are you a designer/architect/decorator interested in sharing a residential project with Apartment Therapy readers? Contact the editors through our Professional Submission Form.






White Enamel Flatwa...
A feast for the eyes.
Your place is fabulous! I see you like to collect chairs/stools among other things. Ah to have more room. I'm a chair/stool lover, too. I mourn two chairs I left in the last rental...seven years ago and I still miss them.
I absolutely love your bed and the color you did in that room. All your different rugs throughout, too. Your yard. Wonderful. The room with the fire must look magical at night with all the candles lit.
Thanks so much for sharing! Hopefully you won't get to many cowhide and sheepskin rug remarks. ;)
This is my favorite house tour ever! I love seeing someone who has a lot of fabulous stuff and knows how to put it all together without making it look cluttered. I adore everything about this house and want to just move in!
Obviously, your guests are very lucky!
Your home is completely and utterly fabulous! And it appears to be so comfortable and cozy as well. This is my favorite house tour EVER as well.
It's lived in and looks homely... gorgeous but not staged... =0)
SWOON!
UNBELIEVABLE!
BEST HOUSE TOUR EVER!
Please can I swap places with your dog? (actually, the dog can stay, as long as I can come too)
Wow...who can possibly hate on this? And I usually hate everything or something in it. This house tour is/was great.
WOW! I love it!
This house is amazing. So much personality and so many details to look at. For once, I don't mind the numerous close up shots because there's just so much to look at. And the dog is adorable (and very sleepy).
Wow! Just added this to my favorites. One of the best tours I've seen in some time. Tasteful, eclectic, fashionable, individual, warm, lived in, wonderful. Bit too many chairs for me but hey, its not my place! Love the Kitchen and that back yard is amazing! Great, great home. Congrats!
Love, love, love it. One of the best tours ever!!!
So refreshing to see a house tour that isn't staged for photography... looks wonderfully comfortable and lived in.
So NOT my style but I'm so humbled by her love of cooking, entertaining and her friends. Her home DOES show that it is set up for guest and to be sure they are comfy.
I would like to come over ;)
warm and cozy......
Fabulous & wonderful...thanks for sharing with us Susan!
What do you do to keep that beautiful white sheepskin rug clean? Do you have to dryclean it at least once a year? Do you brush it out?
Amazing space!
I love your place. Two questions, is that an animal skin on the kitchen floor or is it fake? How do you maintain it? Just love your place!
There are so many things that I love about this house. It is so warm and cozy. However, it drove me crazy that so many drawers were open or ajar. I wish I were the type of person that could overlook that. My husband is! And I just go around all the time pushing in drawers behind him.
One of the best house tours I've ever seen. Very warm. I especially love the outdoor areas.
This house gives me anxiety, it's so jumbled and chaotic. I just want to clean it up!
wow. who knew blogging paid so well? :)
soooo stunning!!
siiiigh, that piano room! and the garden! and omg, THE RUGS
best house tour ever!
Lovely, warm and welcoming house. I live in a similarly configured SF Victorian and it's always interesting to see what other people do with the same kind of space. However, these flats are notoriously poorly insulated for sound and I can hear my neighbor playing the piano for hours everyday--fortunately she's a concert level pianist!
Oh, what a mess and I love it all! Looks like my place (but a lot larger.) Would love to curl up with a drink on one of those chairs and read some books.
I love this place.... can I come over for a party (and never leave)?
The car door is cool
She's lived there two years? I pity the movers! But just lovely.
A feast for the senses!
Oh the plushness!! Could barely get past the plants, the yummy rugs, all the goings on in the kitchen (!) only to find...a piano. Le sigh...I miss SF... :)
That's an incredible place. It is so spacious, all the rooms seem to go on and on.
The only thing I could not piece together from the pics is whether the leather couch behind the front door is already part of the living room? If so, that would bother me (the LR completely open to the front entrance).
Love the rugs. I don't understand how Susan can have cow hides in the kitchen - I am very messy in the kitchen so I cannot imagine not having a floor that I can wipe clean.
The orange orchid - swoon. The garden. What's the orange (or is red) paint on the wall?
Love. What are the wall colors you used?
I, personally, could not live in this much clutter but still, I somehow feel that were I your neighbor, I'd visit every weekend and linger.
My parents have that Restoration Hardware couch and I can attest it is one of the most comfortable couches I've ever sat on.
LOVE this house. You can tell there is a lot of love in this house. She must have amazing parties where people never want to leave. I normally like minimalist spaces, but this is just fabulous. Glad I don't have to dust it, though.
Absolutely love your home. The building details are right up my alley, although I'd do it up contemporary. But I love the lived in feel of the house. It really looks comfortable & relaxing!
There's a little too much stuff for me but otherwise I love it. I am particularly enamored of the way Susan mixes pieces from different periods and makes it work. That is what I want to do. Houses that are all one period look like museums or show rooms. This is comfy and welcoming and lived in.
My God, Susan...you're like a mad scientist...or an alchemist, maybe....or something along those lines. Whatever, your house says that you really know how to LIVE! Viva MacTavish!
I am a bit confused about placement of furniture and different time periods of furniture, but if it works for you...go for it!
Need a roommate, Susan? This is definitely one of the best tours of all time. Please, AT, more tours with personality like this! (And fewer tours featuring neon furniture, FOR LIKE EVER posters, mustaches, etc.)
This is the first time in a long time I've gone through a house tour twice instead of ending it halfway through. I love this place! I wish I had more of a sense of how the rooms flowed into each other (as usual), but that's not your problem. You have such great taste!
some additional thoughts here: first of all, I think Susan and I would be best friends in another life. I adore your style woman! Second, I'm not a hater of the cow hides, but like the other comment, I do wonder how you keep them clean in the kitchen! Mine would be absolutely covered in crumbs, sauces and a myriad of other things by the end of each week...and three, what colour of orange is that on your walls? I absolutely love it! Oh yeah...one last thing - no covering on your bathroom window? I'd hate to be pulling down my pants at night...just sayin'
Love the family room; from the built ins to the natural light-only suggestion is to get a different floor covering for the kitchen/dining area-the one shown makes it look like milk was spilled on the floor...
it's funny to me that on any other post, there would be 50+ comments complaining about your animal skin rugs, but because you happen to have a beautiful home, no one has mentioned it. i don't mind the rugs, i just think it's funny how people are so uppity in every other post except this.
anyway, i LOVEEEE your home. it reminds me of the coziest b&b i stayed in during a stay in philly. i just want to move in and live forever.
what are those branches in the living room? how are you keeping them green?
Dear Apartment Therapy,
We want to see more homes like this! We want lived-in, loved homes, which we can relate to. This home is authentic, and we appreciate it.
Thanks!
Beautiful place. As someone who's lived in the Bay Area a long time, I can't help but wonder what the rent is on the place -- 3,000 square feet in Pacific Heights? Unless she's been there a long time under rent control, I'm going to estimate at least $6,000 per month.
Well, it doesn't suck to be rich, that's for sure.
I love it, of course, it's perfect. 3000 sq ft in San Francisco. The mind boggles. Sorry, but it is impossible not to feel enormous envy.
"it's funny to me that on any other post, there would be 50+ comments complaining about your animal skin rugs, but because you happen to have a beautiful home, no one has mentioned it."
I was ready to mention it. Distinctive style, if a bit cluttered for my taste (but I can see how it's the perfect amount for others!). Makes me sad to see so much dead animal around an animal lover. Your dogs are great. I love that you kept the original tile (I'm assuming) in the kitchen. Great plants too.
Wow. Feast for the eyes. You really have a ton of stuff. Like, a ton. Hard to believe you've only been there 2 years. I imagine you are settled in for awhile, I wouldn't like to move it all back out. It is nice to see a lived in home.
Back story is here....
http://www.sfgate.com/style/article/Susan-MacTavish-Best-wants-you-to-unplug-unwind-3600407.php
Every comment collection has to have an outlier and I will be the one for this tour. Ms. MacTavish does, indeed, have exquisite possessions and a beautiful house. She seems like an interesting person and judging by some of her statements on display, we would be of one mind on many subjects. But I could never live in her home. I certainly couldn't "unplug and unwind" there.
If I woke up in that bed and saw all that STUFF piled everywhere, no matter how beautiful, historic, or nostalgic, I wouldn't be able to arise and function. I might even hyperventilate, or maybe it would just be an allergy attack. People tell me I'm creative. There are things I collect. I'm not a neat freak or germaphobe, but this crosses some line for me.
To each her own and normally I wouldn't bother to criticize. It's not the home that provoked me as much as the number of swooning reviews. One wonders if all the messy readers of this blog now think their chaos is a "style." There's a difference between homes that are unstaged and homes where burglars were searching for microfilm. I am most especially referring to the lovely glass-door display cases flanking the fireplace. All those objets stretched from wall to wall, yet those cases are EMPTY. Seriously, that has to be purposeful irony.
Finally, I trust Ms. MacTavish doesn't entertain too many elders, toddlers, or people with poor eyesight. Open drawers, small things scattered over the floors, and oddly shaped throw rugs are dangerous to them.
Interesting and imaginative home but I can't get past the fact that she keeps a bowl of footsie roll pops in the BATHROOM.
Too many books. Too much art. Too many plants! Too much good food. I object.
Love the coziness but the clutter gets to me -- especially in that back yard. While the yard looks like a curated junk yard, the living room is so warm, inviting and comfortable.
Regarding the animal hides and misconceptions...Did you know:
- some (read: quality) hides are byproducts of the meat industry? Glad to see they go to good (and *gasp* more sustainable) uses. If you get it from the right place, you buy free-range humanely cared for European hides.
- hides are very easy to care for and maintain? Sweep away crumbs, easily wipe away spills, pick up and shake out dust.
Hides are very naturally repelling of our dirty/clumsy ways...After all, how many stained cows do you see in nature?
Completely agree with jokesgrrl ,the only difference is that I am a neat freak.Beautiful house no doubt,but in my case I can never live there,the stress from not being able to clean everything and every single detail on a daily basis will overwhelm my mind and kill me.
No jukesgrrl, YOU are what's wrong with the world. Some people like sterile homes with color coded books and others like a little more chaos in their lives. Most tyoe B personalities (you know, creative types) like to have lots of visual and tactile stimulation to get those artistic juices flowing. Type a peeps... don't. There's nothing wrong with either way of living if it facilitates your interests. I always have all my paints and paintbrushes out because the colors and textures imspire me to paint. If I don;t paint I turn into a raging #itch! My mother, on the other hand can't stand a mess and keeps everything carefully put away in drawers. If there are dishes left in the sink at night, she turns into, you guessed it, a raging $itch. Different strokes, dude. Don't hate! You don;t have to be friends with messy people but don't think you are better. Cause you are not. We are all a$$h0les here!
My only question for Susan is, how do you ever leave this amazing space? I wouldn't be able to go outside without wanting to plop down and relax on all those great couches or cozy nooks! I just know it smells great too! Beautiful from top to bottom. Thank-you for opening your home to all of us!
the "what would a WASP do?" blog is hilarious! I learned so much reading it. my parents might have been involuntary WASPs, minus boarding school education.
from the sfgate article on her, it seems as though many of her guests are young tech types and other movers and shakers making professional connections... (probably elders and toddlers are in short supply)
love this tour... please adopt me!!!! lol
AAAAH STUFF!
This has to be my All time favorite house tour. You are brilliant Susan!
Beautiful!!!! Can u please share the white paint name for walls and trim? Perfect backdrop for all of your decor and furnishings!
A feast for the eyes indeed. Delightful. The only thing I'd change is a window treatment on the gallery/bathroom. If only just for the neighbors.
A beautiful and inspired space... Thanks for sharing!
I, just like another reader mentioned, had to go through this house tour twice. I found no clutter, no mess, no "stuff" on the floors. What I did find was a story hidden in each table. I found journeys and memoirs and tales of other countries. The plants inside the home provide the perfect balance. The backyard is nothing short of magical. I always enjoy house tours and think of ways I would adapt the homes to fit my style, but this time around I can honestly say I would not change one single thing about this home. I have a 5 year old daughter and would have no problem with this environment as I feel one teaches children to appreciate things around them. I can agree that this place will not please all, or most, but for those who strive to create this type of inviting, artistic, and whimsical atmospheres, this place is a perfect fit. Bravo!
Cowhide rugs? In the kitchen? While I enjoy the style quite a lot, I really question how she keeps all those animal skins clean.
Oh wow I like the Pepsi cooler.
Finally, a home on AT that actually reflects some signs of life! This is the most beautiful, personal tour yet. Some may object to the "stuff." But real life is messy, and one can tell that, in this home, a lot of living is going on, and it is a life with a purpose and vision. It always cracks me up when people chime in with what they would change about a dwelling that belongs to someone else. It is obvious to me that Susan doesn't need anyone's advice, particularly regarding the removal of items that are meaningful to her. Our homes reflect our souls; or they should, anyway. In the end, time is really the only "stuff" that matters, and I would rather say that I lived in a messy and spirited home than to regret having spent too much precious time compulsively cleaning it.
wow! beautiful...
The sheer size of your house is wonderful - and you have filled it with the most wonderful things! I love your art, and that it is meaningful to you. And I wish I could try some of that cooking. Mmmm..
Also I love the sunroom with your desk, and the plants. A very welcoming home.
...too much for me...thanks for sharing:)
A girl after my own heart! Chairs for days. Love it. Never seen a San Francisco house so bright...(sunlight).
I love this place! Full of stuff and books and a crazy kitchen with all sorts of delights, gorgeous comfy places to sit and lounge about, an intimate and cozy party house, so welcoming! I esp. love the chaises, you can plop down anywhere with a drink, a pet and a book, what else do you need to be happy?
I love this house. All of those woolly rugs...it makes it look like the rooms are perched on clouds. And I adore the stacked hides in the kitchen, and all of the large plants...This house is amazing.
I commented before that this seems to me to be a lot of stuff... What I meant was that my OCD is running rampant. Crooked hanging mirror, open drawers, pictures hanging on nails in window trim, pictures taped to the wall, stacked magazines and books and more magazines. I really appreciate the things she has acquired however everyone would have a different version, as a designer I can respect that. This one is just not for me. To each his own. Cheers!
crikey, this is what my house would look like if i went crazy and bought every rug and chair i ever wanted! My cleaner would fire me, and my family move out so I must restrain. Looks very homely and cosy for the owner..just for me to higgeldy piggeldy and full.
All that means is that she's subsidizing the meat industry.
There are worse things, sure, but it's a fair point to make.
I just registered to be able to comment how much I adore your style and love for life. This is my first comment and I've been following AT for several years. Your tour was worth a comment.
I own a vintage shop that reflect my personal style which is so many different eras and styles from ancient to modern and your home reflect my life style perfectly! There is no reason to pick a style or era when you can have all that you love!
Thank you,
Susan and AT