We've done our own list of the best non-toxic paints on the market, and we were pleased to see many of our recommendations approved by The New York Times in their recent independent study.
Zero V.O.C paints have come a long way in only a few years ago. It used to be that low and no-V.O.C. paints suffered from quality and consistency issues, but now V.O.C.-free paints are mostly on par with regular paints in terms of quality and come in almost as many colors.
The test was conducted in three parts: first, paint was applied to a primed wall and left to dry for six weeks; second, it was smudged with newspaper-stained hands to test for cleaning ease; and third, it was marked up with red and black permanent markers and then repainted, to gauge how many coats it took to cover up the markings.
The New York Times tested the following paint brands:
- Farrow & Ball
- Stark
- Benjamin Moore's Natura
- Safecoat
- Yolo Colorhouse
- Mythic
How did they stack up?
The overall winner (from our reading) was Benjamin Moore's zero-V.O.C Natura line. It "can be tinted more than 3,000 shades — the most of any paint here — and it went on the smoothest. Its smell was mild and a bit fruity, the most paint-like of any here, and it had a soft sheen, slightly less matte than the two above. It cleaned up better than the more expensive brands (although the fingerprints never completely disappeared), and it easily covered the ink marks."
Safecoat and Yolo Colorhouse were some of the easiest to clean. The inky fingerprints wiped away quickly without the need for excessive scrubbing.
Read the whole article at The New York Times.
Related Posts:
• Best Eco Paints 2009: No-VOC and Non-Toxic
• How To: Buy the right amount of paint
• Good Questions: Low VOC Paint?
Image: The New York Times

Comments (8)
I use Sherwin Williams "Harmony" and I never see it in any of these zero VOC lists - is it just not as major of a brand, or is there some other reason it never makes the cut?
Sagekitten85, we included Sherwin-Williams Harmony in our list of the 2009 Best Eco Paints, and we agree that it's a very good option.
we've used all freshaire from home depot so far...but i tell you what, it takes about SIX coats till it's thick and good looking! i'm TOTALLY going to try the benjamin moore on our next DIY/painting project...any hints on where to buy? we just bought a house so i'm a newbie :) cheers
http://www.casacullen.com/
Mythic is also sold as American Pride - it's the less cutesy markety version but the same paint. I prefer Yolo to Benjamin Moore because I like supporting smaller businesses, but yeah, the Natura line is amazing.
We recently used Yolo paints to redo our bedroom. The colors look great, and we were able to sleep in the room almost immediately (very little odor).
I use Olympic from Lowes. Almost no odor/VOC and cheap. Anyone can pay/charge lots of money for quality materials but only the affordable materials represent any real value or savings.
safecoat and green planet - amazing, both of them.
being someone that has multiple chemical sensitivities, I have found mythic to be my absolute favorite. The best quality and the highest integrity with most natural ingredients.
Yolo is great on the ingredients, yet I have heard many complaints about the quality. I still did a room in it, because it is a very safe option. Didn't smell much at all, and I love the company. Yet, the painter did not like using it at all...