Scraping with a metal scraper has been very time intensive (and not terribly effective), but I worry about the toxicity of paint remover (I have two cats). Any advice? P.S. I most likely will not want to replace the actual tile--can't invest that much time and money into a rental!
Editor: Leave your suggestions for Ari in the comments — thanks!
• Got a question? Send us yours with pic attachments here (those with pics get answered first).