I'm a computer nerd plagued with a strong tendency to overplan — often taking preparations to near-OCD extremes. I take the same approach to DIY's I attempt to tackle by using Sketchup to precisely plan and visualize a project. As I was sketching up plans for my next DIY project, for the home, I wondered for a moment how others might go about this. What types of DIY planners are out there? What type of DIY planner are you?
The way we plan our DIY's is likely accounted for by a mix of the type of person we are, and what's worked for us in the past. I've seen some people who go to the same extremes as myself, while others on the opposite side of the spectrum just "throw something together" — beautifully I might add. Here are some of the design types I've encountered.
The Engineer
This is the type of DIY planner I am. They'll measure the room in question dimension-by-dimension, and then make digital mock-ups in Sketchup or Photoshop — or both! They'll tell you they went through all the trouble to sell their significant other on their vision. But really, they just like doing it and getting a chance to live with the design a bit before spending any money. They tend to think that since they did so much pre-planning, the project can be completed in a single day. It often takes weeks, but the result makes it all worthwhile.
The Bold & The Adventurous
These are the types that save a bookmark or two of something they like — or maybe even just keep mental notes — before one day heading out to the store on a whim. They'll haphazardly round up supplies and gear, then bring it all home to piece together. They'll come up with a few hacks, maybe even leave out a few screws, but it'll eventually come together, work, and look gorgeously unique. This person may or may not be your dad.
The Day-dreaming Artist
This is the type of person that may carry around a moleskin notebook and a fountain pen. They're inspired by the world around them — not just the world within the interwebs. They'll make beautiful sketches on napkins or paper tablecloths and modestly dismiss them as 'just doodles.' Their finished pieces tend to come out even better than the sketches because of some last minute inspiration.
The Hunter-Gatherers
There are two types of these DIYer's — the virtual and the actual. The latter will piece together physical collages — tearing out pages from a decor mag or gluing on fabric samples before settling on that perfect color palette. The former types will use online pinboards such as Pinterest or some of the design apps we've rounded up in the past. They'll struggle to find an exact color match or just the right shade of wood, but they'll eventually come to a compromise that'll still look fantastic.
What type of DIY planner are you?
(Images: Chris Perez)


White Enamel Flatwa...
It really depends on the DIY. Our house feels like it's been owned by various "bold and adventurous" and "daydreamer" types, and I would like nothing more than to give them all a good lecture on taking care of a home. Screws being left out, doors being uneven, etc. might seem like hilarious stories to tell your friends, but it's a nightmare of a situation for whoever will buy your home. We keep finding mistakes and shortcuts made by previous owners.
I take the engineer's approach to nearly everything I do, and it's always better than the other approaches when it comes to large projects like kitchen redesign or bathroom renovation, or projects that require precision.
While I consider myself a mix between the Engineer, and the Bold and Adventurous; I'd like to be more like the Day-Dreaming artist. Specifically, I'd like to be able to draw more like that. Any suggestions on where I can learn to do this?
thought the picture on the top was an electric chair...a DIY electric chair? Dark.
@PI, spot on! My recommendation for anyone who is trying to sell a home - don't remodel your kitchen or bath, instead make sure that the house is solid.
I too am an Engineer (or should it really be an Architect?). The previous owner left our house a mess of half done projects and half the battle of remodelling the thing is fixing all those little things that were neglected.
Ha @JohnJake! That does look like an electric chair now that you mention it.
It's actually a light box project I was sketching ideas for. Guess I'm going to have to make some changes so my house doesn't look like it has an electric chair in it :)
Category 5: Architect. Fortunately/unfortunately I'm a licensed architect so virtually everything I DIY is one or more of the following: drawn in CAD, mocked-up, agonized over, discussed with coworkers or anyone who will listen, agonized over again, filled with self-doubt, discussed with dear 'ol Dad....repeat ad nauseum. It can drive my husband nuts. He loves the results, but not the design process. He is The Bold and Adventurous...without the good results ;)
I just go for it. Learn as I go...Some have come out beautifully and other's, well, they look like a 3 year old did the DYI. :o)
I am more Bold and Adventurous but have learned from experience when it's better to be an Engineer.
The cool thing about Sketch-Up is you know instantly when your sofa needs to be further from your fireplace... ;-)
It is my favorite tool.
@James Gardner, I recommend books by Francis D.K. Ching. A spontaneous drawing lesson here:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=QUDpqBtobcs
I think I'm an engineer but I keep the vision in my head with a few measurements written down... my husband thinks I'm successfully hap hazardous.. but that's because he can't read my mind and I don't bother to show him my vision before it's done.. teehee..
@johnjake that was my first thought as well!
I’m a Make-Things-Up-In-My-Head-That-Will-Probably-Be-A-Huge-Pain married to a list-making, graph-paper-loving engineer. Let me tell you how much he loves when I hand him a drawing compiled from my imagination, not drawn to scale, or taking into account walls, floor plans, existing structures… and say—this is what I’m thinking…
When we were first married, he could get away with telling me that something “couldn’t be done.” But now? I know better.
@ Duane Hill
Yes, thank you, that should be 'Architect'. As far as I know engineers don't yet do kitchen designs...
I am an inexperienced DIY-er, so I can only call my style "Haphazard." I always forget to measure everything before purchasing the parts, This means that I have to make several trips including the one back home to pick up the paper with the measurements on it (once I finally have them). For this reason- I don't DIY things often!
First, I daydream a lot, then and doodle sketches of what I want. Then, I get Bold and Adventurous. I am totally over-confident and always think 'I can do that' and I just jump right in.
In the middle there's always a Period of Darkness, when I am humbled by my own limitations, wonder how I have, once again, gotten into this fix, and vow never to do it again. Then, I usually have a cup of tea, google my problem, figure it all out and move on.
I've never had a big fail because I just keep going until I like the result. Sort of like saying you never get lost, because you've ended up in the right place after driving around in the dark for hours looking for it.
Throw me in the category of folks who thought that was a sketch for a DIY electric chair. Glad I'm not alone in my macabre ideas.
@ Duane Hill
Thanks for the video! I look forward to trying after work :)
I start as a scrap-scribbler type, hopefully working out potential problems while doodling designs on any blank piece of paper that's handy. Once I get past that stage it's tape measures and layout rulers and pencil and paper. Sometimes graph paper. Sometimes I colour the drawings, definitely add notes, then modify, refine, erase, scribble, redo, whatever as required. Eventually an actual item emerges, occasionally resembling the plan.
A long time ago I was an Engineer. I was not happy with our living room's layout so I took some graph paper, mapped out the living room on it, and cut out all the furniture pieces to scale. Then I rearranged to my heart's galore.
Now I'm Hunter-Gatherer. I look for interesting furniture, accessories, fabrics.
I have everything in my home drawn in Autocad to an eight of an inch. I study and brainstorm and figure for hours. I'm told I'm most dangerous when I'm found staring at a room for hours -just pacing around.
Then I head to the hardware store, buy far more stuff than I end up needing, ignore the drawings and I hack something together that magically seems to work out quite well.
It's a strange balance of intense studying and planning followed by off the cuff whatever works methodology. Fortunately I tend to over build so there's nothing flimsy or cheap about my work.
My dad's an actual engineer, so his DIY style is also Engineer, with the advantage of a whole heap of tools (granddad was a construction supervisor and amateur woodworker) and engineering software.