One option would be to make some yourself - find an animal you like (maybe here) and have it printed on linen or twill at Spoonflower, then just sew up a pillow cover. Any animal you want! The perfect size & shape!

Dang--lemonadefish beat me to it! Spoonflower is the way to go-- and dropcloths from the hardware store paint department are a good source of lots of cheap,printable fabric in any color you want (as long as you want "natural"). This is my go-to site for printable images: http://vintageprintable.com/wordpress/
Good luck. Please post pics of your finished work!

West Elm has a line of animal print pillows. The last line was birds and sea creatures. I think the sea creatures are gone but the birds are on sale right now.

Areaware might be an option.

Thanks for the suggestion - West Elm does carry bird pillows. I seem to prefer the mammals in the photo above.

Thanks for the idea! Areaware pillows are very unique, and closer to what I'm seeking. Unfortunately, they're not square. I'm also looking for higher quality colors, as the Areaware pillows are sepia-toned.

This. There are a couple different sites that have great downloadable & printable images of animals, and I've tried to post a link to my favorite, but I think the link is what keeps getting my comment deleted! So, I'm just gonna say.... what @lemonadefish said. Good luck!

Also, Urban Outfitters just added some pillows on their website that feature large images of animals (the pillows are actually cut to the shape of the image). I'm not sure they're exactly what you're looking for, but they might be fun to mix in, and they sure are cute!

Try searching on Etsy!

West Elm, as someone already said. But I've seen some new pillows just the other day at Pier 1 that had animals on them and I thought they looked very similar to Robshaw's pillows. Maybe check your local store out?

I can't remember exactly all that I saw, but I'm remembering an elephant, a zebra and maybe a giraffe?

Good luck!

Thanks for the great suggestions! I love the sleeping fox at the Urban Outfitters site. I have checked etsy, but was overwhelmed by the variety.

I didn't know I could order an image on fabric. That is a clever suggestion!! While I don't sew, I could take the fabric to a tailor. I'll keep this in mind!

Any local print shop should be able to do it for you. They can print onpractically anything. Look for some stock pictures or drawings of animals and download them.

John Robshaw is very expensive - be happy they don't sell them any longer!

While it is a bit pricey at times, soukshop.com always seems to be carrying animal-printed pillows.

look at www.hm.com, they have a home section with similar pillows

Not exact, but here are a few similar ones:

http://www.wayfair.com/Kevin-OBrien-Studio-Deer-Decorative-Pillow-DEE1420-OVB1158.html

http://www.wayfair.com/lava-Deer-Etching-Pillow-012193751355-LVY1232.html

http://www.wayfair.com/lava-Bear-Etching-Pillow-012193751270-LVY1229.html

http://www.wayfair.com/Fauna-Zebra-Pico-Pillow-SFBPZ1-FNA1013.html

Not exact, but here are a few similar ones:

http://www.wayfair.com/Kevin-OBrien-Studio-Deer-Decorative-Pillow-DEE1420-OVB1158.html

http://www.wayfair.com/lava-Deer-Etching-Pillow-012193751355-LVY1232.html

http://www.wayfair.com/lava-Bear-Etching-Pillow-012193751270-LVY1229.html

http://www.wayfair.com/Fauna-Zebra-Pico-Pillow-SFBPZ1-FNA1013.html

Not exact, but here are a few similar ones:

http://www.wayfair.com/Kevin-OBrien-Studio-Deer-Decorative-Pillow-DEE1420-OVB1158.html

http://www.wayfair.com/lava-Deer-Etching-Pillow-012193751355-LVY1232.html

http://www.wayfair.com/lava-Bear-Etching-Pillow-012193751270-LVY1229.html

http://www.wayfair.com/Fauna-Zebra-Pico-Pillow-SFBPZ1-FNA1013.html

Hey all! You may be surprised, but society6.com sells interesting pillows, art, iphone cases galore. Here are some their artists animal pillows: http://society6.com/pillows/animals?page=2

Looks pretty similar hm? It's a great website for finding neat little things or different art.