Despite passionate opinion otherwise, some of us here at Unplggd are very interested with progress and features of the Android platform (though our readership seems to veer strongly one way according to this open poll). You see, what's exciting now is we've got two major developing operating systems vying for market dominance, specifically on mobile devices like smart phones and tablets. And on that note, one of the most promising devices we saw at CES this year was the Motorola Xoom, sparking much talk amongst Android followers about a viable alternative for those who didn't want anything with "i" in front of its name. You may want to wait a little longer...
Although the Xoom garnered much praise and hype at this year's CES, I remember taking all the marketing hyperbole on the show floor with a grain of salt, knowing a device at a tradeshow is rarely the device we get once released into the wild. And although the Android OS for tablets, codenamed Honeycomb, is a promising start, this beautifully in depth review of the Motorola Xoom over at Arstechnica outlines many reasons why you might want to just wait a little longer for Google's push into tablets to ferment into something more polished.
Ars reviewer, Ryan Paul:
My experience with the Xoom feels like a similar situation. The product has an extraordinary set of features, but the best are simply not available at launch. While I was testing the device and studying the documentation, I was confronted repeatedly with disclaimers which explained that various features will arrive later in updates. There are so many of these disclaimers that it soon became absurd. The device, in its current state, is like a parade of promising placeholders.
Comments from other Xoom users seem to mirror many of the criticisms and notes made about the devices potential, but shortfalls of actual delivered features, with too much mention of "eventually" (the most ironic is the inability to play Flash files and the crippled, unoptimized browser). Does this mean Android for tablets is DOA? Hardly...if history repeats itself, it seems this is just the 1st salvo from Google and licensing manufacturers, with Android likely to overtake the iPad by sheer numbers within several years (the optimistic may think sooner). But the review makes for an insightful read why the Android platform has yet to be adopted by non-tech types and by the mainstream for now. Here's to the hopes of a better Xoom 2.0.
More at Ars reviews the Motorola Xoom by Ryan Paul.
Comments (6)
I pretty much agree with much of this except for the "xoom 2" comment. much of the "not ready"-ness is a software issue, not hardware. in terms of hardware, this tablet beats the iPad in many aspects. when the software improves, it will make the "xoom 1" that much better.
First of all, your premise in the first paragraph is based on a poll based on Smartphones, rather than laptops. In this poll, you make the same mistake all Apple disciples do; you compare a piece of hardware to an operating system. If you compare operating systems, there are 59 readers who want an Android system and 76 who want an Apple OS, which is only available in an iPhone. Considering the preponderance of Apple users on this website, maybe your readership doesn’t veer quite as strongly as you originally thought.
One note about the poll ... the poll was, as I read it, what smartphone should YOU get. Personally, if the guy sitting next to me at work asks me what smartphone he should get and my mom asks me what smartphone she should get, I will give two different answers (of course, my answer to my mother would be the same answer I gave her when she asked if she should get a hybrid car - "you don't need it").
Now, I am sure many of the respondents answered with their own personal preference, but, to be fair, this is not what the original poll was...
I agree with the first commenter. The hardware is excellent. The software is very green but will mature fast knowing Google. Xoom 2 is not needed as much as Android 3.1.
I don't think this post really makes its point clear. And anyway, is it really fair to compare a product at a trade show to an established product like the ipad? Clearly if a product is not ready for sale, you would not buy it.
Completely agree. There is no hurry. I own the xoom and would love to see more and better apps but in time and I still am glad to own it. Buy now and grow with the flow.