This Waterproof Mattress Pad That Made Our Best List Is So Soft and Quiet, You Won’t Even Know It’s There (And It’s on Sale!)

published Feb 23, 2023
We independently select these products—if you buy from one of our links, we may earn a commission. All prices were accurate at the time of publishing.
Post Image
Credit: Sylvie Li

I don’t often eat or drink in my bedroom, but when I do, one of my biggest fears is spilling something that causes a big mess on my bed. Fortunately, I have cleaners that will knock out any stubborn stains fairly quickly; but what’s even better than that is not needing to unexpectedly clean the mattress at all. That’s where a quality mattress protector comes in. Parents, pet owners, the accident prone, and those of us who like to enjoy drinks and food while watching TV in bed deserve the assurance of organically grown and non-toxic materials, too. And that’s where Naturepedic, whose company motto is “comfort without chemicals,” comes in. After developing the very first organic baby crib mattress designed with a patented food-grade waterproof surface, the brand now has organic mattresses, bedding, and protectors for the whole family. Their Organic Waterproof Mattress Protector earned a well-deserved spot on our mattress pad Best List as the Best Waterproof pick after scoring high points with our tester. 

Part of what makes Naturepedic’s Organic Waterproof Mattress Protector so impressive is that it provides a liquid-blocking barrier for your bed without the noise of plastic that comes with others on the market. In fact, it’s whisper-quiet, slides on like a fitted sheet, and makes an excellent choice for those seeking out organic bedding. It’s made from 100 percent organic cotton jersey and has a lining of medical-grade, GOTS-certified organic pure polyurethane that helps to keep your bed dry and stain-free despite messy accidents or spills. Several reviewers even mention that after buying these for their kids, they went ahead and bought them for the rest of the beds in the house — a testament to their quality and comfort despite being waterproof mattress protectors. Aside from its standard uses, one shopper mentions using it unconventionally against pet messes: “I use these to cover my bed so that my dog can be on top of it at any given time, and I don’t have to worry about her having an accident or getting any hair into the sheets! I highly recommend it if you have animals!”

Naturepedic‘s Organic Waterproof Mattress Protector comes in six sizes, from twin to California King, and fits mattresses up to 16” thick. As it blocks liquid from penetrating the mattress pad, it allows water vapors to pass through, effectively releasing heat and assisting with humidity and sweat reduction. Some reviewers also say they got better sleep after adding the mattress pad to their bed! “I purchased two XL twin mattresses protectors for my Sleep Number bed that has two separate mattresses, and they fit them perfectly.” begins one review. “After sleeping they get a few wrinkles but it is not bothersome to lay on. The material is very soft and comfortable. I don’t feel like I get overly hot with them on like other mattress protectors. I’ve washed them several times now and I can tell they are great quality. No issues with threads coming loose or the fabric fading. It’s such an awesome purchase, and I would definitely buy again for future needs.”

For those on the fence, Naturepedic has a 30-day money-back guarantee, and the mattress protector comes with a limited warranty that lasts for a year. Between our tester and the reviews, the reason this mattress pad beat out other waterproof options is clear: It’s simply the best!