With the popularity of high-end California Closets and mid-range Elfa systems, the more basic underdogs are often overlooked — here are 5 sources for CHEAP closet and shelving systems to get you started organizing on a budget.
Whether your turning your second bedroom into a giant walk-in closet or converting a tiny hall closet into a pantry, proper installation means a lot with budget systems — take weight restrictions seriously! Most mishaps occur when inexpensive components are loaded up with TOO MUCH STUFF.
Rubbermaid
Rubbermaid is a giant company and offers what is perhaps the most basic, most accessible closet system — I find their products to be the easiest to understand in a timely manner and Rubbermaid products (of one system or another) and its many components are available at nearly every hardware store (Home Depot, Loews, Ace, etc.) and large retailers (Target, WalMart, Amazon, etc.). Rubbermaid has many different closet systems in their vast collection: HomeFree, FastTrack and DirectMount. I found that their online tool for helping to choose which is right for your needs very helpful: Rubbermaid Closet Designer. These systems are designed to be simple, modular and reusable (you can take the pieces down and move them or reconfigure them). Components in the closet system are primarily wall-mounted track, rods, shelf brackets and Rubbermaid has a wide variety of shelves in different sizes and finishes.
IKEA
IKEA has two systems for closet organization — ANTONIUS is primarily designed for clothing and BRODER is designed for bigger, heavier items. Both are inexpensive but you'll find there are many more accessories like nylon bins, drawers and laundry accessories, casters with ANTONIUS. BRODER is best for basements, garages and heavy-duty storage. BRODER has the added benefit of stability: the wall brackets are also supported by L-shaped legs on the floor.
ClosetMaid
On the surface ClosetMaid appears to be very similar to Rubbermaid — except it is not nearly as self explanatory or understood as quickly (this is especially true when you compare the clunkiness of the Closetmaid website with the slickness and ease-of-use of Rubbermaid's site). The basic ShelfTrack system requires a bit more planning than other systems in the beginning stages but has an impressive number of components and accessories.
Martha Stewart Living at Home Depot
The newest product collection on this list, the Martha Stewart Living for Home Depot is fairly basic. The basic starter sets are made of wood (particle board) with a melamine finish. Closet systems have few options until you add in the many accessories like bins, drawers and specialized hangers (quickly adding to the cost).
Easy Track
Found primarily at building supply, lumber stores and independent hardware stores (and Amazon!), Easy Track is a 95% wood (particle board) with a single rail that all of your components hang from (like Elfa). There are a few basic starter kits that can be combined and customized with additional kits and accessories.
What is your experience with these closet systems? Share your stories in the comments!





Comments (17)
Best closet system I've ever come up was in the only double door closet in my house, which is of course, not in a bedroom. I repurposed an old cheapy of a bookcase (think the $30 ones from Target or Wal-Mart) and added a bar that sits just above it all the way across. The half of the closet with the bar holds coats on the top and bulky items like spare chairs/Rock Band drum kit. The half with the bookcase holds ugly paperbacks I don't want displayed, games, extra blankets, etc.
oh man, i'm pretty sure we had a bigger version of that easy track system in our closet when we first moved in to our house. it is *not good* if your walls aren't exactly straight/plumb. we kept coming home to find the hanging rods collapsed on the floor.
we upgraded to elfa. more expensive, but we are so much happier w/ it.
Closets always look so pretty when all of your clothes are the same color...and you only have nine items of clothing and five pairs of shoes! This looks like the closet of a cruise ship activities director....except...WHERE ARE HER PANTS?!?!?!
I absolutely hate those wire closet shelving systems. With a Kreg Jig and some melamine covered particle board from Home Depot you can easily build something much cheaper and nicer.
I had a cheapy wire system in my last place and I hated it but I didn't have the bars where you could slide all your clothes over.
I've been dreaming of an Easy Closets system; you can design your own closet on the website which is so incredibly tempting. Not as cheap as Rubbermaid but a lot less than California Closets and the reviews are generally good. Maybe this tax refund check.
I didn't know there was anything other than ClosetMaid until I was well into college. I think it does just fine for a small closet, as long as you follow the above advice and watch the weight limitations. That said, the closet displays are my favorite thing in the Ikea store.
Awesome. I was at the Container Store the other day drooling over their Elfa systems, but their online design tool is sadly lacking and no way to adequately price out what I want to do in our master bedroom closet.
The last few closet posts I've seen here on AT seem to be missing the Ikea Stolmen love... It is a bit more expensive than a lot of their other storage systems, but it makes up for it with its nearly infinite hack-ability.
I know Elfa is more expensive, but with a coupon or their yearly sale - I outfitted an 8 foot closet for $300 with a 2 foot hanging area and 6 feet of 5 levels of shelving. 4 levels are melamine and 1 is wire (top shelf). I love, love, love the ease of installation and that I can reconfigure it anytime I want!
You know what i need help with?? I have a triangle shaped closet, and no closet systems work with that unless you stop using one wall which makes no sense. *sigh* Even rubbermaid has no solutions.
I use Elfa and as long as you stick to the basic bars and shelves, it's not expensive and can be changed any time. Ask to remove all the special bits (like end and track covers) that automatically get added when the computer generates the plan, they are completely unnecessary.
I love the Rubbermaid system! It's so easy to install and customize.
I have Elfa in 2 closets. I only have one complaint, the freestanding mesh drawer system. I tend to fill up any space I have in my clothes closet. So, to be fair, the drawers are overflowing. Items on top of each drawer are getting ripped by the mesh drawers above when opened and closed, I've lost 3 of my favorite shirts (course the favs are stored on the top). With that said, I did really like the purchase process in the Container Store, I spent around 3 hours with dedicated associate working through perfect set-up to maximize my limited closet space.
Why do the closet system examples have so few clothes in them?
I've been leaning towards the Ikea Stolmen since I saw the one style blogger Susie Bubble installed. I have a lot of clothes, but if that thing can deal with her wardrobe, my comparatively miniature one should be no problem.
I think this is the link, but my Internet is borked right now: http://www.stylebubble.co.uk/style_bubble/2010/08/say-stoooolmen.html
Great piece!
I have a caveat about wall-mounted systems. Unless they are screwed very well directly into the studs, the system will collapse. I've had this happen many times.
I absolutely hate those wire closet shelving systems. With a Kreg Jig and some melamine covered particle board from Home Depot you can easily build something much cheaper and nicer.
free standing closet