When Ashley and her husband bought their 1930s rowhouse in 2007, they were recent graduates with little money to spare to fix the place up. Faced with a very dated kitchen, they embarked on an inexpensive DIY effort to update their small kitchen. After a couple of years living in the space, and inspired by a neightbor's more comprehensive renovation, they started their kitchen reno part deux and created a wonderful space that will work for their family for years to come.
Here is the tale of Ashley's kitchen in her own words:
"The previous owners had occupied the house since the 60s and that's about where the decor was stuck. The kitchen had these orange-y wood cabinets, faux cobblestone Formica in shades of brown and orange, and the flooring was a competing pattern of linoleum tiles. We had just graduated from college and had no more than a couple hundred dollars in our bank account, so our initial solution was to paint the cabinets white and install black and white sheet vinyl flooring after ripping up the old stuff. As for the counters, we basically tiled right over them and put up this cheap backsplash that looked (from afar) like tin. This first re-do cost less than $1,500. And that worked for a long time.
Then one day we visited our neighbors, whose house exactly mirrors the layout of ours. They had taken down the wall separating the kitchen and the dining room, creating a really open feel that was perfect for parties. My husband and I exchanged glances and knew right away that's what we had to do. Then, during the winter (a.k.a. crazy period of non-stop blizzards) of 2009-10, we took the plunge. We demolished the kitchen and went to Home Depot to pick out our new stuff - white wainscoting cabinets, black and white granite counters, a breakfast bar separating the kitchen and dining room, slate tile, new appliances, and dark gray walls (Elephant Skin by Behr). Unfortunately, we were without a kitchen for a couple of months, since the snow kept delaying our progress; we ate a lot of fast food that winter! In the end, we're so happy with the style we chose, as we obviously went the opposite direction from the oranges and browns that used to characterize the kitchen."
As Ashley's experience shows, it is possible to make a big impact with a small investment while deliberating a more monumental change. That first round of kitchen updates made it possible for Ashley and her husband to live in the space and get a better feel for what they wanted in a final kitchen. Whether you don't have the money for your dream kitchen or haven't yet figured out exactly what that dream kitchen will look like, you can still make some small changes to bridge the gap between your dramatic before and after!
Thanks Ashley for sharing your pictures and your story with us. If you would like to see more pictures of Ashely's kitchen, you can see pictures of the original kitchen, pictures of the first renovation, and pictures of the final product on her Flickr stream.
Images: Photos by Ashley Henley, used with permission.




Shaw's Original Fir...
LOVE the yellow ceiling and how you didn't paint over the wood - it goes wonderfully with the finishes you chose. Well done.
agreed. love the yellow ceiling.
I like the renovation but I kinda prefer the "midway" stuff. It looked a bit dated and retro, sure, but it also had a lot of charm that matched the rest of the house, since it's an old house. But I do agree the yellow ceiling is great though personally I would have chosen cabinets that go all the way up to the ceiling. But on the whole it's really a nice kitchen.
Awesome job! Looks great... Now here come the "why didn't you keep the knotty pine!?" comments... ;)
Whoa! MAJOR improvement!!!
Thanks for the Flickr link! I loooove the new breakfast bar. The temporary kitchen was nice, and the final result is amazing :)
Love both the midway and final version. The final definitely looks brighter with more natural light.
The yellow ceiling is yummy.
great job on both!
Improvements in both steps. Great job!
Good job on both designs!
While the midway and afters are definitely more my usual style I think I might fall into the "would've kept the wood" cult with this one. It looks like it was in such nice condition. I think switching out the countertop, backsplash and wall paint, flooring, and putting on different hardware would've gone a long way to making it seem less orange and more "warm" and made the cabinets the real highlight of the room. The after is certainly pretty and an improvement but at the end of the day, not much to write home about design-wise, I think.
The first and current stage are my favorite! I thought first stage had full of character! And, current stage is so refreshing yet cozy. I like.
I guess I'll be the one that isn't a fan of the new kitchen. The old had so much more character, the new just looks like a new house and every other kitchen I've seen. I especially miss the curved accents.
Oh the middle one is so cute and cozy!
I like all three stages, each one appeals to me for different reasons. Kind of cool that you got to live with all three! I think the middle phase was my fave, but you made smart upgrades for the final phase. Tile countertop is just not fun to keep clean!
It does look quite beautiful. However, my fave is the middle.
LOVE the middle one. Black-and-white checkered floors and the deco cabinet pulls are adorable.
I think they did a great job, and it sounds like this will work better for the way they entertain.
But they must have had a wall oven before, which I would have loved.
imho, kitchens need to *work*. They need to make your life easier. So design for design's sake might be great, but I dunno if that's necessarily the only laudable end of a kitchen. When we gutted our kitchen, we paid attention to materials that we could afford and that would *last*. That gave us granite and Teragren bamboo floors. I know granite is trendy and overused, but it is also a hard-working and beautiful bit of stone. Ikea cabinets may be everywhere, but they still look good and have been designed with hard use in mind. The high-end hinges with the stops you can add are a dream come true. =)
I loved the middle! It was updated yet maintained its vintage charm. Once again, I find myself feeling that the final version is nice but generic. I seem to have this reaction to a lot of kitchen renovations.
darlingcaro, word...
When I designed my new construction kitchen, the last thing I worried about was how unique the design looked. I worried about function, durability, budget, storage, comfort and if it was easy to clean. I did have a certain color cabinets and countertop in mind and wanted the kitchen to look bright, of course. Granite is used quite a bit not just because of trends but because it is hardworking and beautiful. Contrary to what many people believe, not all granite is high maintenance, it just depends on which color you get.
I really like both "afters!" My own kitchen is somewhere closer to their first low-budget update, and I know it has some vintagey charm. But if theirs is anything like mine, it looks much better in photos than it feels to work in there in real life. They did a great job making the room look better in the first update, and the final version not only looks good but is probably an enormous improvement to actually use.
Please explain why you would replace solid-wood white cabinets for what I'm guessing are not-solid-wood white cabinets. It also seems that storage space was lost by installing that stove. Seems a similar effect could have been achieved, while saving a lot of money, by just replacing the counters and doing some painting. (JMO)
I am sad to see that you got rid of the wonderful cabinets that were there before, they had such character to them. i would have been a bit more enviro friendly and tried to paint them...
Though the final kitchen is nice, I LOVE the midway kitchen much more. (More my style.) It had loads of character and that metal backsplash was fantastic!
While I'm certain that the "upgrades" are great for resale value, I'm aggravated every time I see someone rip out period cabinets and replace them with something that will be incredibly dated in a decade or so. Those cedar/pine cabinets were classics....vintage craftsmanship at it's finest. To each his own, I suppose.
great job replacing those dark ugly wood cabinets. They really had to go.
I would have stuck with the midway. I just hate when old homes are gutted and walls torn down. 10-20 years from now people will be putting the walls back up. Even though the original kitchen was updated in the 60s, the craftmanship of that era is hard to match today. The final product is lovely, albeit generic, but I would expect to see something like that if the original had been falling apart or something. I guess I am old fashioned.
Excellent Job!!
Good god you really cleaned up well. good job
I liked the "before" best though I would have changed the walls (is that wallpaper?). Not that I am against paint I just don't see that it added anything.
Love the midway version! It's warm, inviting, and joyful. I feel like cooking when I see it. I love it as it is, and don't feel the need to change it (unless you don't like the tile counter).
The "After" is generic. It's cold, and unwelcoming. Granite counters aren't everything! As I look at it, I am mentally thinking what I would change about it.
I'm sad about the final outcome.
I like the After's window treatments.
But I like the solid wood cabinets of the Midway.
I can see the appear of stone tile over sheet flooring, but am a sucker for checkerboard and wonder if something that was the best of both could have been worked out.
Actually, looking at the cabinets, its like the wall cabinets of the After are good, (I do like the beadboard) but I still miss the Midway bases. And the bin-pulls were nice.
The yellow ceiling is gorgeous! But I like the first renovation step better! I would've kept it like this....
I wish I had those old kitchen cabinets instead of the crappy 1990s ones in my kitchen. Your new kitchen is lovely, however. I think the first renovation is super charming though!
Well done! I think the new kitchen is gorgeous!
Loved the knotty pine. Unless you spend big money for custom, the newer kitchen cabinets these days are not very good.
I like the 1st reno the best. It had such charm and personality. The second one is fine, but nothing special.
Number two looks pretty much like mine does right now. We did the cheap and effective update too, although I went butcher block instead. I also like number three. Good job on both.
Ooh, I really like them both. I'm always a sucker for checkerboard flooring.
It's unbelievable when people think fugly knotty pine cabs are beautiful. Beauty is in the eye of the beholder, obviously.
Gorgeous reno!
I agree with thorndale. :(
MyDogistheShih Tzu: I think most people like the white paint on the original cabinets rather than the pine cabinets.
rhodajr - the post did say she took a wall down to have a more open design, I assumed this is why the stove was installed, it was likely on the other wall in the original.
I don't really get the love of knotty pine, it would drive me crazy, painted or not, but I tend to lean modern so that's probably why.
People who say that she should have kept the original cabinets or just painted them don't realize how not user-friendly old cabinetry can be. We did a similar kitchen renovation, and I got the same reaction when I shared photos. I would choose new high quality cabinets any day over drawers that are difficult to open and close and cabinet doors that won't stay closed!
Looks beautiful and functional! Good job!
I like the look of the mid-way the best, although I'd say the tiled countertops definitely had to go. I did like the checked floor, but I guess they would have had to get an entirely different countertop if they'd stuck with it.....
Beautiful kitchen! I have a very small kitchen and it is VERY outdated! I am looking to do something really nice and trying to effectively utilize space the way you have! I think I am going to opt for marble countertops instead though