A Damaged Secondhand Dining Table Got a $25 Redo

Megan Baker Detloff
Megan Baker Detloff
I cover home upgrades, DIY projects, hacks, how-tos, and plants. I’ve written about home decor and renovations for more than a decade since earning my degree in Magazine Journalism from Northwestern University. Before AT, I was an editor at HGTV Magazine and This Old House Magazine.
published now
Add Us
See more Apartment Therapy stories when you search on Google.
We independently select these products—if you buy from one of our links, we may earn a commission. All prices were accurate at the time of publishing.
About this before & after
Home Type
N/A
Project Type
Cost
Skill Level
Rental Friendly
Before: Dining table with gray wood stain, surrounded by caned dining chairs

If you’re in the market for fresh furniture for your home but are hitting stocking issues or shipping delays, here’s your reminder that you can often get exactly what you want secondhand — as long as you’re willing to put in a little work.

The Solid Wood Table Was a Little Beat-Up but Worth the Elbow Grease

DIYer Monica Aberle (@surreyridgehome) scored this West Elm wood dining table off of Facebook Marketplace for a steal. The only problem: It was a little beat-up, with a bare patch where the old owner had started sanding down the finish (and quickly gave up).

She Had to Change Her Plans After the Original Scuffs Wouldn’t Absorb the New Wood Stain

“It was a great shape, though,” Monica says. “I loved the clean, mid-century modern legs the table had — it just felt like it needed a new life.”

At first, Monica sanded down the whole table with the intention of giving it a different stain finish. But the patch that was previously sanded ended up having some wood filler that wasn’t absorbing any of the new color.

She Chose a Neutral Paint Color That Fit with the Mid-Century Style

“To be honest, when it wasn’t taking the new stain, I was ready to part ways with the table,” Monica says. “But then, I decided it wouldn’t hurt to try giving it a coat of paint.”

So, armed with a new plan, Monica purchased furniture and cabinet paint in an off-white color (Benjamin Moore’s “Pale Oak”). The project cost just $25 to pull off and only took two hours — and in the end, Monica ended up loving the results.

It Looks Straight Out of a Catalog and Brightens the Whole Space

Now, the creamy white dining table is surrounded by wood dining chairs for a setup that looks straight out of a catalog — but is still plenty welcoming.

“Sometimes a change in direction produces a final result better than the original vision,” Monica says. “I thought I’d miss having the table a light wood — but honestly, I don’t! The light color brightened the whole room.”

Shop This Before & After