This Outdated 1950s House Checked None of Their Boxes; Now It’s the Dreamiest Home

Despite their realtor showing Lauren and her fiancé, Nathanael Cook, “everything from sleek new builds to untouched time capsules,” nothing felt right to Lauren until this 1162-square-foot house built in 1955, much to the surprise of Nathanael.

“The house checked none of our boxes. It was outdated, a little quirky, and did not match anything on our wish list. No walk-in closet or third bedroom here, but it made up for it in character,” Lauren writes. “My fiancé looked at me like I had lost it, but I was already sketching out ideas and mentally rearranging every room. That is how certain I was.”

Lauren says it is a “true 1950s home,” though it had been altered over the decades, a challenge Lauren was eager to take on. “The floor plan reflects those layers of tweaks and remodels, and our goal wasn’t to erase them completely, but to edit them so the house feels intentional again. Balancing updates with restoring what had been changed while keeping its original heart intact became my focus. The bones were solid, the details were honest, and it felt like stepping back in time.”

> Ask a question & discuss this Tour in our Community Forum!

“In a world that often celebrates new construction, I am partial to homes with history. They have a character that cannot be replicated. Houses from that era were built with a permanence and care you rarely see today. The challenge and the joy has been bringing it into the present without erasing the past.”

It wasn’t just with the house’s architecture that they honored history. They embraced the past with many of the furnishings they filled their home with: “Many of the pieces came from my grandparents’ mid-century ranch home in El Paso, and bringing them into my own space has given them a new chapter.”

“My grandfather lost my grandmother when I was 17 years old. I didn’t realize it until a decade later, but at that point he started labeling pieces he wanted me to have: on Post-its, taped to tables, and sometimes notes written directly on the furniture itself,” says Lauren. Paired with other vintage finds they have carefully collected, these add to the home’s final look as a “mix of mid-century furniture, collected art, and inherited treasures, giv[ing] the house a sense of balance that feels modern yet anchored by history.”

> Ask a question & discuss this Tour in our Community Forum!

• Foyer — Benjamin Moore “Cloud White (OC-130)”
• Living Room — Benjamin Moore “Cloud White (OC-130)”
• Dining Room — Benjamin Moore “Cloud White (OC-130)”
• Kitchen Walls — Benjamin Moore “Cloud White (OC-130)”
• Kitchen Cabinets — Benjamin Moore “Natural Cream (OC-14)”
• Bathroom Walls — Benjamin Moore “Cloud White (OC-130)”
• Bathroom Beadboard & Molding — Benjamin Moore “Classic Gray (OC-23)”
• Bedroom — Benjamin Moore “Cloud White (OC-130)”
• Office — Benjamin Moore “Cloud White (OC-130)”
• Deck — Behr Premium Advanced DeckOver “Cordovan Brown (SC-104)”
• Deck Trim — Sherwin Williams “Alabaster (SW 7008)”

• 1948 Singer Sewing Machine — Etsy
• Vintage Mid-20th-Century Brass Quails Partridge Family Figurines — Chairish
• Taupe Textured Terracotta Vase — Etsy

• Large Vintage Hollywood Regency Golden Gilt Convex Sunburst Mirror — Chairish
• Vintage Mid-Century Modern Speaker Console — 1st Dibs
• Mid-Century Modern Club Chairs — Chairish
• Vintage Hollywood Regency Faux Bamboo Chinoiserie Coffee Table with Glass Top — Etsy
• Vintage Landmark Chair by Ward Bennett for Herman Miller — DWR
• Handmade Marble Chess Set — Etsy
• Vintage Stoneware Jug — Chairish
• Vintage Eero Saarinen Tulip Side Table for Knoll — 1st Dibs
• Textured Pillow — Etsy
• Floral Woven Rug Rust/Green — Target
• Jolene Checkered Marble Coaster (discontinued) — Anthropologie 
• Gather Sofa — Crate & Barrel
• Kiki Taper Candles, Set of 2 — Anthropologie

• Drexel Heritage Hollywood Regency Campaign Pedestal Extension Dining Table — Chairish
• Drexel Heritage Accolade Collection Rustic European Cane Back Dining Side Chair — Chairish
• Drexel Heritage Mid-Century Hollywood Regency Campaign Carved Walnut Cabinet — Chairish 
• The Eloise Scallop Milk Glass Pendant Ceiling Light — Anthropologie
• Scroll Hook Candleholder — Brooke & Lou
• Glossy Ceramic Octagon Vase — Target

• Vibora Knob — Residence Supply
• Round Brushed Brass Cabinet Pulls — The Boutique Handle Co
• Tiffany Stained Glass Transom Window Panel — Amazon
• Delacour Bridge Kitchen Faucet with Side Spray — Signature Hardware
• Vintage Green Ceramic Bunny Rabbit Lamp — Etsy

• Vintage Campaign Dresser by Dexel — Chairish
• Vintage Campaign Nightstand by Drexel — Chairish
• Vintage Campaign Headboard by Drexel — Etsy
• Vintage Godinger Silver Crystal Glass Lotus Lily Candle Stick Holder Set — Etsy
• Modern Silk Stripe Bolster Pillow — West Elm
• Washed Linen Bedspread — Zara Home
• Unique Wave-Patterned Bowl — Etsy 

• Vintage Mid-Century Modern Walnut Nightstands — 1st Dibs
• Bella Milk Glass Table Lamp — Pottery Barn
• Essential Linen Cotton Bed Skirt — Pottery Barn
• European Linen Duvet Cover — Quince
• Handwoven Natural Jute Rug — Etsy
• Amaroso Linen Ruffle Bolster Pillow — Lulu and Georgia
• Lavelanet Linen Pillow — Lulu and Georgia
• Textured Basketweave Knit Throw — Pottery Barn
• Antique Anchor Hocking Clear Prescut Candy Dish — Etsy

• Vintage Campaign Desk & Chair — Etsy
• Vintage Brass Bankers Desk Lamp Light — Chairish
• Vintage Landscape Large Framed Wall Art — EasySuger
• Antique Rug — 1st Dibs

• Orren Ellis Herwarth 16.5-inch White Resin Rectangular Drop-in, Trough Bathroom Sink — Wayfair
• Orren Ellis Herwarth Accent Cabinet — Wayfair
• Orren Ellis Herwarth 28-inch Single Bathroom Vanity Base Only — Wayfair
• Bhargava Large Arched Mantel Wall Mirror — Wayfair
• Two-Tone Waffle Weave Cotton Bath Towel — World Market
• Two-Tone Waffle Weave Cotton Hand Towel — World Market
• Apothecary Hand Wash — Frama

This tour’s responses and photos were edited for length/size and clarity.
Share Your Style: House Tour & House Call Submission Form

> Ask a question & discuss this Tour in our Community Forum!