I Changed Up the “Favorite Things” Gift Tradition, and Now I’ll Never Do a Regular White Elephant Party

Steph Mickelson
Steph Mickelson
Steph Mickelson is a freelance writer based in Northwest Wisconsin who specializes in real estate, building materials, and design. When she's not writing, she can be found juggling kids and coffee.
published now
Add Us
See more Apartment Therapy stories when you search on Google.
We independently select these products—if you buy from one of our links, we may earn a commission. All prices were accurate at the time of publishing.
A person handing a large green checkered gift wrapped with a burgundy ribbon, surrounded by smaller wrapped gifts.
Credit: Photo: Alex Lepe; Prop Styling: Tom Hoerup

Gift giving during the holiday season can feel overwhelming — especially if you have no idea what to buy. That’s why the “Favorite Things” gift tradition, which is a twist on a typical White Elephant party, is my favorite way to celebrate with my friends. 

At a regular “favorite things” gift exchange, you buy everyone your favorite thing (so if there are four people, you bring four of the same item). But over recent years my friends and I have actually added another twist to the “favorite things” party, and it’s become my new favorite holiday tradition.

Credit: Stephanie Mickelson

A Fun Twist on the “Favorite Things” Gift Tradition

My friends and I started doing a “favorite things” gift tradition back in 2017. Since then, we decided to add another layer onto the tradition. Nowadays, we pair our gift exchange with a fun activity. One year we had a cookie baking party at my friend’s house, and brought all of the kids. While they were occupied elsewhere, we did our gift exchange — and one of us learned to use a stand mixer. Another year my friend had an igloo set up at her home, and she surprised us with the coziest gathering complete with pizza and a Christmas movie. 

Last year, the “Favorite Things” gift exchange didn’t actually involve gifting. Instead, we each took ownership over an activity of the night. Instead of gifts, we decided on a night out and broke it into four parts: dinner, activity, drinks, and desserts. To keep things even more interesting, about a month before the planned night out, we met for dinner and chose our respective activities out of a hat. Then on “favorite things” night, we found out who had what and what they had planned. I was responsible for dinner, and we went to the Chinese buffet (one of my favorite places in the world). Our activity was pottery, planned by the friend who has taken quite a few pottery classes. After our activity, we decided against desserts in favor of late-night appetizers and combined the those appetizers with the “drinks” portion of the night at a place that both friends loved. 

Credit: Stephanie Mickelson

Other Ways to Put a Twist on the “Favorite Things” Gift Tradition

Over the years, our “favorite things” nights have become part of our friend vernacular. If anyone says that they really love something, we’ll all say, “guess we know what we’re getting this year.” Or if one of us finds something particularly funny or horrendous — a weird painting or tchotchke — while we’re out and about or scrolling online, we’ll text the group that that’s what they’re getting for “favorite things” this year. You can definitely stick to a traditional “favorite things” party, but there are a few other ways to put a fun spin on the tradition.

  • Choose a theme: It can be serious or silly, or not even make sense outside of your group. Some ideas include blue (anything that’s blue counts), food (bring your favorite food), self-care, something to read, or something under $10.
  • Go to a fun location: We’ve often met at one of our houses, but you could also go to a restaurant or plan another activity as a backdrop. Bonus points if it’s holiday-themed, like ice skating or a sleigh ride. 
  • Exchange coupons: If you want to keep the budget low or just want to share your skills, you could do a coupon exchange for things like landscaping, a custom craft, house cleaning, baked goods, childcare, or anything else that you’re good at!

More to Love from Apartment Therapy