9 Wayfair Mattresses Shoppers Swear by for Great Sleep, Starting at $154

published May 24, 2024
We independently select these products—if you buy from one of our links, we may earn a commission. All prices were accurate at the time of publishing.
Post Image

When it comes to affordable home retailers, there’s a lot to love about Wayfair. With a little bit of just about everything for your space, Wayfair is the definition of a one-stop retailer. Looking for a stylish new sofa? You’ll find it here. How about some chic outdoor furniture? You’ll find that, too. You can even nab top-notch cookware from brands like Cuisinart, Le Creuset, and Ninja. But one of our favorite pieces to score at Wayfair? Mattresses

The Best Wayfair Mattresses 

It’s no secret that buying a mattress is one of the most important purchases you can make. However, they can also be notably pricey. If you’re looking to find a solid mattress and a price you can be proud of, make Wayfair one of the first places you scope. Below, we rounded up nine of the top, best-selling mattresses on Wayfair. Not only are these picks affordable, but they’ve got thousands of rave reviews to back them up.

Do you have a Wayfair mattress you love? We want to hear all about it. Tell us about your favorite mattress in the comments below. 

1 / 9
Wayfair
$169.99
was $299.99

With over 43,000 five-star reviews, this medium memory foam mattress is the definition of a fan favorite. Made of high-density quilting foam and padding, this mattress features a slim profile and medium firmness for a mattress that carefully contours to your shape for the coziest feel. Designed to eliminate all pressure points along your body with an open-cell foam design, it also features green tea infusion, making your nightly sleep the ultimate moment of zen.

2 / 9
Wayfair
$429.99
was $819.00

Looking for a hybrid mattress that’s on the softer side? Check out this plush cooling gel mattress. Combining modern gel memory foam with classic pocket coils for support, the construction is designed to relieve pressure in your body as you sleep while still being breathable, keeping you from overheating. To top it off, this mattress is also compatible with adjustable bases, beautifully detailed with a quilted euro-top knit cover, and has low motion transfer, making it a solid choice for couples.

3 / 9
Wayfair
$339.99
was $999.99

If a firm mattress is what you’re after, shoppers have one recommendation: the Wayfair Sleep Firm Gel Memory Foam Mattress. This solid memory foam mattress has a top layer of latex-like foam that keeps you sleeping on top of your mattress instead of sinking into it, providing more responsive comfort and better alignment. Underneath that, soft and conforming memory foam contours to your body while you sleep to provide personalized comfort that keeps you sleeping peacefully all through the night. Top that off with a cooling gel infusion that helps regulate temperature, and you have what many are calling “the perfect mattress.”

4 / 9
Wayfair
$109.99
was $117.99

A quality queen mattress for less than $160? Yep, you’re reading that right. Zinus is a brand beloved for its affordable sleep products, so it’s not surprising to see shoppers gravitating toward the OrthoTherapy Innerspring Mattress. This medium pick is designed with layers of high-density quilting foam, padding, and strong 13-gauge steel coil units that contour to your body for a peaceful sleep. Best of all, it can hold up to 500 pounds, making it durable and affordable.

5 / 9
Wayfair
$336.99
was $379.99

What is it about this medium hybrid mattress that has shoppers raving? Let’s break it down. This mattress pairs pocket coils and cooling gel swirl memory foam resulting in a mattress that offers premier weight distribution to help relieve any pressure points along your neck, shoulders, back, and hips. Its breathable, low-motion transfer design features a medium firmness making it a top pick for all styles of sleepers. To top it off, it's backed by a 10-year warranty, so you can snooze with a little extra peace of mind. What’s not to love?

6 / 9
Wayfair
$236.99
was $304.99

A dreamy night’s sleep awaits with this cooling hybrid mattress. It features a combination of inner pocket coils and layers of gel memory foam. What you’re left with is classic support and a plush you’ll love sinking into at night. Plus, it features a hypoallergenic, breathable wrapping with built-in cooling technology to help you fall asleep easily, even on the hottest nights. For just $237, it’s a bona fide steal!

7 / 9
Wayfair
$219.99
was $499.00

We’re big fans of Brooklyn Bedding’s mattresses so when we saw its firm mattress topping Wayfair with thousands of glowing reviews, we’ll be honest — we weren’t surprised. This mattress is crafted with a pocket coil design for a little extra orthopedic support, while the quilted, foam-filled euro-top and layer of high-density foam add a plush feel to help you sink into a good night's rest. Plus, it features a breathable design to help keep you cool so you can finally get the sleep you deserve.

8 / 9
Wayfair
$410.18
was $483.10

One of Wayfair’s most popular mattress brands is Nora, beloved for high-quality picks that don’t break the bank. If you’re a hot sleeper looking for something on the softer side, you’re going to love this gel memory foam option. Hugging your body with ease, this mattress also comes with a soft and breathable cool-to-touch cover (made with cooling fibers) that offers an instantly chilly feel as soon as you lie down. No wonder reviewers are calling this supportive yet sink-in cozy mattress “just right."

9 / 9
Wayfair
$389.99
was $1199.00

When you think of legacy mattress brands, Sealy is one of the first that comes to mind — and with good reason! The brand has been making top-notch mattresses for decades now, and the Sealy Cool Memory Foam Mattress with CopperChill Technology is no exception. A great choice for hot sleepers, the star of this mattress is the CopperChill-infused gel memory foam layer that delivers enhanced cooling and moisture-wicking technology so you can sleep through the night without ever breaking a sweat.