16 White Elephant Gifts for Under $25 That You’ll Want to Steal

Stephanie Nguyen
Stephanie NguyenLifestyle Director
I oversee all our coverage of lifestyle topics, which include cleaning, organizing, wellness, entertaining, real estate, travel, and more. I’m based in Honolulu, Hawaii.
Alexa Casanova
Alexa CasanovaShopping Writer
I cover all things shopping, from cleaning and organizing finds to decor and furniture that’s worth every penny. Your home says a lot about you, so I’m always curious about the things people choose to bring into their space — and aim to make it easier to find those things! I’ve written home and lifestyle content for Well+Good and Design Milk.
updated yesterday
Add Us
See more Apartment Therapy stories when you search on Google.
We independently select these products—if you buy from one of our links, we may earn a commission. All prices were accurate at the time of publishing.
A person holding a large green checkered gift with a burgundy ribbon, surrounded by smaller wrapped gifts.
Credit: Photo: Alex Lepe; Prop Styling: Tom Hoerup

The best white elephant parties I’ve ever attended are ones where people are clamoring and trying to steal the hot gift of the night from one another — whether it’s something super funny, genuinely good, or just downright practical that they actually need.

Looking for white elephant gift ideas for an upcoming party? Below, I rounded up the best items that Apartment Therapy staffers recommend bringing to a gift exchange. The best part? They all cost $25 or less.

The Best White Elephant Gifts Under $25

A crossword game, a clever kitchen essential, and a buzzed-about beauty find… These white elephant gifts are sure to be the life of the party.

The Susan Alexandra Sticker Book
$25$23

Everyone at the party will be asking to flip through this Susan Alexandra sticker book. It’s packed with hundreds of whimsical stickers inspired by the designer’s own beaded creations — perfect for decorating anything from phone cases to notebooks. The weighty, hardcover design is one they’ll want to display on their coffee table, too.

$23 at Bookshop
Posh Tech Braided Thread Wire Headphones
$20

Wired headphones are back, and this pair from Anthropologie is wrapped in colorful embroidery thread for a design-forward flourish. Plus, the wrapping helps protect the 4-foot-long cable from ripping and fraying.

$20 at Anthropologie
Voyager UO Exclusive Refillable Faux Leather Journal
$20

Something about the leather look of this journal makes it feel special and covetable — exactly what a white elephant gift should be. The best part is that it’s refillable, so the recipient can use any insert they want, from a blank sketchbook to their go-to planner or journal.

$20 at Urban Outfitters
Blue Q Funny Cotton Dish Towel
$14

“Blue Q makes great gaggy-but-practical gifts, like socks and tea towels,” shares Associate Shopping Editor LJ Smelker. This dish towel in particular will make partygoers (and their families) chuckle with its quippy saying, and the absorbent cotton material makes it more than just a punchline.

$14 at Amazon
“Sizzle” Glass Extra Virgin Olive Oil
$20

Edible gifts are always a hit at a white elephant party, especially olive oil, because let’s face it — it’s expensive. Graza’s Sizzle extra-virgin olive oil is a favorite among food editors and comes in a refillable glass bottle that looks good on your countertop.

$20 at Graza
Hydro Flask Micro Bottle
$23$1822% off

If you think this Hydro Flask bottle is too small to be useful, you’re mistaken. It can hold anything from espresso shots and water to salad dressings and juice shots, keeping the contents hot or cold for hours. It’s also purse-sized and leak-proof, so you can bring it anywhere.

$18 at Amazon
Cartoons from The New Yorker 2027 Day-to-Day Calendar
$18

“I ended up with a desk calendar of New Yorker cartoons for the last two years and honestly loved it,” shares Mara Weinraub, Director of Shopping and Groceries at our sister site, The Kitchn. “It’s practical, and now I look forward to uncovering the cartoon of the day every morning.”

$18 at Amazon
DIY Bunny Besties Beginners Needle Felting Kit
$25

Whether they’re new to crafting or an experienced hobbyist, this felting kit is pretty much guaranteed to pique their interest. It’s an easy, screen-free activity with the most adorable result — what could be better?

$25 at Uncommon Goods
Knock Knock Personal Library Kit
$25

For the group that loves a book swap, this personal library kit will have everyone wanting it. It comes with checkout cards, self-adhesive pockets to keep them in, and a date stamp so you can keep track of a book’s comings and goings.

$25 at Ban.do
Ridhi Hand Block Print Tissue Box Cover
$23

“This tissue box cover has been in my Amazon cart for ages, so I’d bring it in the hopes that I’d end up taking it home,” says House Tours Editor Cullen Ormond. “It’s cold and flu season, after all, so everyone has tissues on hand, and these block-printed covers look so much better than the regular packaging.”

$23 at Amazon
Q-Less – The Original Crossword Solitaire Game
$15

I think I can speak for most people when I say we’d all like to spend less time on our phones, and Q-Less is a great way to get off your screens and get your brain working. Simply roll the letter dice and build as many words as you can out of the scrambled letters. It’s oddly addictive (but better for you!).

$15 at Amazon
Dieux x Fishwife Good Taste Forever Eye Masks
$25

Dieux’s reusable eye masks are a buzzy beauty find that would cause a stir at a white elephant exchange — and in this limited-edition Fishwife design, they’re the gift everyone will be clamoring for. They’re incredibly cute, and the washable silicone helps lock in any eye cream you put on underneath to boost absorption and efficacy.

$25 at Fishwife
Hasbro Gaming Bop It!
$20$1525% off

Looking for a fun and enviable gift idea? Go for full ‘90s nostalgia with a Bop It! The fast-paced party game is a bona fide rush and will bring out every attendee’s inner child. Just be prepared to pass it around so everyone can have a turn.

$15 at Amazon
FULNIX Shower Lamp
$24$228% off

If this shower lamp turned up at my white elephant exchange, I would be all over it. Fully dimmable with 15 color settings, it will take everyday showers to the next level. Set on a beechwood base, it looks extremely elevated for the price.

$22 at Amazon
Apple AirTag
$29$2321% off

An Apple AirTag may seem a little too practical as a gift, but honestly, you probably know at least one person who is always losing their phone, wallet, or keys, and could really benefit from having an AirTag on hand.

$23 at Amazon
A&J Koti Table Crumb Sweeper
$12

“Personally, I love a little cute tabletop crumb brush,” shares Executive Producer Meghan Smith. This mini one includes a dustbin and has built-in magnets to ensure you never lose a piece of the set.

$12 at Amazon

Want more gift ideas? Check out our Gift Therapy guide — which highlights the best gifts for everyone on your list, from practical gems to thoughtful finds and even cozy products.

More to Love from Apartment Therapy