These “So Soft” Pottery Barn Cotton Sheets Are the Only Ones I’m Keeping on My Bed from Now On

published Oct 2, 2024
We independently select these products—if you buy from one of our links, we may earn a commission. All prices were accurate at the time of publishing.
Natural light-filled bedroom with orange and white bedding in a neutral painted room.
Credit: Erin Derby

I’m not ashamed to admit that I lounge in my bed a lot, especially on my days off. I haven’t always been a self-proclaimed professional bed rotter, though. Up until this past year, I rarely idled in bed beyond the hours that I spent sleeping. What changed, you may be wondering? The quality of my bedding. Before, my mattress was too firm, my sheets were too rough, and my comforter was too thin. I endured, never making my bedding a priority. It also had something to do with being on the budget of a college student back then.

These days, I know better — I’ve discovered that even something as seemingly minor as sheets can make a world of difference in how solidly I sleep through the night. The right set will also make it so that I never want to emerge from my cozy cocoon. I’ve tried so many different kinds of materials since starting this gig, from linen to bamboo to a cooling nylon blend, but I still find myself going back to classic cotton more often than not, especially during the fall months. My new go-to for the season? Pottery Barn’s Favorite Tee set, which is as soft as its name suggests.

What is the Pottery Barn Favorite Tee Organic Sheet Set?

Claiming to be as “comfy as your favorite tee,” this cotton sheet set is made of jersey rather than percale. The former has a lived-in, thicker, marshmallow-like feel to it, while the latter has that crisper, hotel feel. While I’m certainly a fan of percale, I think there’s nothing better for fall than jersey, especially when it comes from a quality brand like Pottery Barn. The material is entirely organic, certified by the Global Organic Textile Standard, which ensures that it’s free of harmful chemicals and meets certain sustainability levels, pollution standards, and fair worker protections. The fitted sheet offers universal elastic around the entire edge for a secure fit, and the included pillowcases have an inside flap to keep the pillow in place. To top it all off, it has no special requirements for washing!

Credit: Pottery Barn Teen

Why I Love the Favorite Tee Organic Sheet Set

I knew before it arrived that all of the above qualities would put this set over the top for me, and boy, was I right. My expectations were already high because Pottery Barn has become my favorite bedding source by far — in fact, my current setup includes a comforter and quilt from the brand in addition to my new sheets. Upon taking it out of the packaging, the soft feel floored me. In my experience, it usually takes several washes to achieve the cloud-like softness that this set has right away. After my first week of use, I hurried to wash it and put it right back on my bed.

Its weight is the perfect middle ground, not as breezy as my summer sheets and not as heavy as my winter flannel ones. The loose-knit pattern of the jersey gives it a stretchy quality that makes getting it on my bed completely painless; it also doesn’t bunch up, which is my eternal peeve with other sheets. The jersey also looks as gorgeous as it feels; if you go with one of the colored or striped options, the material’s heathered effect looks just like a well-worn T-shirt. Wrinkling is another aspect of sheets that I can’t stand, but this material seems entirely resistant to it. Even unmade, my bed looks more put together thanks to its pristine appearance.

This set isn’t budging from my rotation any time soon, and if you’re on the hunt for an easy bedding upgrade for fall, you’ve found it. Plus, Pottery Barn is offering free shipping on orders over $99 with the code HAPPY. If that isn’t a sign to add this set to your cart, I don’t know what is!

Buy: Favorite Tee Organic Sheet Set, Queen, $119

AT Deals and Steals

Find the top deals on products you love by signing up for our weekly Deals & Steals newsletter today.