Is Quince Worth It? These Are Our Editors’ Honest Opinions About the Buzzy Dupe Brand

I don’t remember when exactly Quince took over the internet, but at one moment in time, I considered it an under-the-radar bedding and clothing brand with suspiciously low prices. I even noticed that when my colleagues started reviewing its blankets and sheet sets, their posts usually had an underlying tone of, “I’m letting you in on a special secret.”

In what felt like no time at all, though, I was suddenly seeing Quince everywhere: in Tiktok hauls, in skeptical Reddit posts, and even in my neighbors’ mail room cubbies. Not only was Quince literally all over the place, but its product categories kept expanding, too. Slowly but surely, its offerings crept into every facet of daily life, turning Quince into a sort of one-stop lifestyle shop for everything from flatware to leather loafers.

Because most people who know me know I test products for my job, I’ve even gotten a few questions from friends about whether Quince is trustworthy. If I were an average consumer, I’d be questioning its quality, too. Luckily, my coworkers and I have tested countless Quince items spanning multiple categories, so we can collectively answer this question with our honest thoughts.

I’m sure you’ve noticed that many of Quince’s products are made from luxurious materials, namely leather, silk, and cashmere. Even more intriguing is that they’re offered at significantly cheaper prices than similar items from competitors. Even materials like cotton and linen go for bargain prices when you look at other brands selling bedding and clothing. To offer such comparatively low prices, Quince uses a factory-direct model. Essentially, it sources directly from manufacturers, eliminating intermediary parties like warehouses and distributors and cutting costs in the process. Additionally, the brand claims to employ low-cost designs for its products, as well as minimal packaging and corporate overhead costs.

Also of note is Quince’s product labeling and fabric compositions. While the brand says it seeks out organic materials when it can and prides itself on its sustainability initiatives, some of its products labeled as “wool,” for example, are actually made of a wool blend. Case in point: This baby alpaca wool sweater is, indeed, made from baby alpaca wool and merino wool, but its composition listing also includes nylon (percentages for each material are not listed on the product page). Many retailers do this, and it’s a common way of offering “luxury” materials for a steal.

We’ve tested everything from bedding to cookware to bath essentials from Quince. Keep reading to see how we liked the items.

I’ll start with bedding, since that’s where Apartment Therapy’s journey with Quince began. Our staffers have tested bedding across a variety of product types and materials, but where Quince is concerned, this European linen sheet set is a longtime team favorite. Contributor Mark noted in his review that the sheets can be used during any season, writing, “They kept me warm during the final days of winter, and because they’re so breathable, they’ve been ideal for summer.”

I compared the sheets to a pricier linen set, and my final takeaway was that the cheaper option from Quince offered the same breathability and moisture-wicking capabilities as the pricier set, for a fraction of the cost.

Two of AT’s employees also highly recommend the European linen duvet cover set. “We used to have a [more expensive] linen duvet, which stained and eventually wore down so much it ripped,” says producer Anne-Marie. “We’ve had the Quince one for about seven months, and it still feels like the day we bought it. The linen material is so soft.”

Maria, AT’s associate art director, owns the same duvet cover and similarly loves it. “I’ve had it since September, and it honestly just gets better and softer the more I wash it,” she says.

If you’re after cooling bedding but you’re not a fan of linen, Quince’s bamboo sheets are a favorite. Vicky, AT’s Studio Director, was initially drawn to the set because of all the pretty colors it comes in. “The color range options let me mix and match with a few different quilts and blankets to refresh my bed every month,” but over time, she really fell in love with the quality: “I love the bamboo sheets in the summer and winter — they’re soft, cooling, and stay put nicely on my mattress.”

If there’s one item that best exemplifies Quince’s pursuit to offer category-dominating products for less, it’s the hard-shell carry-on suitcase. If you look at the suitcase’s product page, a brand comparison table makes it obvious that this travel essential is an Away luggage dupe.

Contributor Mark owns both, noting in his review of the budget-friendly option that, “Quince’s suitcase looks a lot like my Away carry-on, right down to the tan color of its polycarbonate shell.” He added that, “like the Away, the Quince also features spinner wheels, a TSA-approved combination lock, a removable laundry bag, and an interior compression system.”

In my own post comparing the brands, I wrote that if you don’t care about recognizable brand names, Quince’s suitcase gets the job done just as well as Away’s carry-on. Besides, Quince has arguably become just as big of a brand name.  

Two contributors have tested and swear by Quince’s down alternative pillow, which is available in three firmness levels and two sizes. What’s more, the pillow has a hypoallergenic microfiber fill, which is great for people with seasonal allergies, and a cotton sateen shell that’ll help you stay cool all night. 

“It truly has a hotel-quality feel, offering the perfect blend of comfort and support,” contributor Haley wrote in her review. “As someone who frequently switches positions throughout the night, I’ve found this pillow supports me no matter how I’m sleeping — even if I end up putting it between my legs!”

Speaking of bedding finds worth shopping, I nominate my textured faux fur blanket. I received it in October and have not taken it off of my bed since, even as the weather has gotten warmer. It’s the perfect layering piece; I keep it draped over the foot of my bed for the aesthetic, and if I wake up shivering in the middle of the night, I pull it up over my lightweight quilt. I was worried that the faux fur would pill or become matted after washing, but after multiple washes on a cold, gentle cycle, the blanket still looks as good as new.

Quince has some other great blankets, including this waffle blanket, which is a reader bestseller. It’s so popular that it tends to go out of stock frequently, so I’d recommend keeping an eye on it. AT shopping writer Megan Gray has the velvet quilt and immediately fell in love with it. “It brings a retro, yet elegant, fall vibe to my bedroom. The weight is ideal for cooler weather, though my only complaint is how much it tempts me to stay in bed all day.”

Quince also sells kitchenware, in case you didn’t know. Lifestyle shopping writer Morgan owns and loves the brand’s stainless steel frying pan, which she reviewed for our sister site, The Kitchn. The pan comes from a family-owned Italian factory that’s been developing cookware since 1925 and has a durable five-ply construction of stainless steel and aluminum. 

“In addition to cooking shockingly fast, my fried and scrambled eggs slid out of the pan with hardly any residue left over,” Morgan noted in her review. “The little that did stick came off in seconds with a little dish soap and my sponge, and thanks to the comfortable handle and surprisingly manageable weight, it’s easy to hold over the sink.”

Morgan also owns and has reviewed Quince’s cast-iron Dutch oven, which appears to no longer be available. Even when it was in stock, it was constantly sold out. I asked Morgan how her Quince cookware has held up since she reviewed it, and she told me that both pieces are “still in tip-top shape.” Who knows? Maybe Quince will bring back its best-selling Dutch oven in the future!

Finally, two of our team members have tried the Gia Minimalist 20 Piece Flatware Set, one in polished stainless steel and one in brushed gold. Megan tried the former and loves how “simple, elegant, and incredibly well-priced” the set it, while Shopping Director Katie Maguire has the gold set and it makes her so happy. “There’s something that feels so elevated and styled — every meal feels like special treat.”

There’s quite a bit of leather on Quince’s website, both in the travel and clothing departments. A couple of summers ago, I was looking to replace my old faux leather work tote, which was literally falling apart. I asked Quince if I could test its Italian leather triple compartment tote and haven’t looked back. Almost two years after receiving it, the leather is still in mint condition, aside from a couple of small worn-down spots at the bottom corners. The tote has also maintained its boxy structure. Considering that I use it for work multiple times per week, I’m beyond impressed. 

I’ve also used this tote as a carry-on because of its built-in laptop compartment and spacious-but-not-too-big size. It even won a spot on our carry-on Best List, and I still highly recommend it. I frequently load it up with heavy items, and the straps have remained secure.

Another great travel find is Quince’s leather jewelry travel case, which Morgan owns. Its exterior is so chic, and the interior has a suede lining that helps prevent jewelry from tarnishing. “I loooooove it,” she says. “When I’m not traveling, I’ve been using it as a digital camera case, oddly enough.” Talk about versatility!

I can’t wrap up this list without mentioning that Quince makes great bathroom essentials, too. Our staffers are especially fond of its bath towels, including this ribbed Turkish cotton bundle. If you prefer thin towels, these aren’t for you. Instead, their plush feel will add a spa-like vibe to your bathroom. Senior Shopping Editor Britt says their ribbed design is unlike that of any other towel she owns, and the material dries quickly despite the high-pile construction.

“After lots of use and multiple washes, the towels look and feel just as nice as they did when they first arrived, including the washcloths and bath towels, which get the most action,” Britt’s review reads. “There are no stains, no fading, no snags, and best of all, little to no shedding.” And, a six-piece bundle retails for just $80.

If your overarching question about Quince is, “Is it a scam?” I can answer that succinctly: No. Sure, not all of its materials and products are of the same quality, but it’s definitely not chintzy like a fast-fashion brand, and most of the products our editors have tested are good for the price, if not great. I’m aware that depending on who you ask, you’ll get varying responses. For example, I know a couple of people who say Quince’s silk skirts wrinkle and pucker terribly, but I love the brand’s silk sleep mask. 

The good thing is, if you do opt to try a product or two from Quince, you likely won’t be spending a fortune — that’s the brand’s whole shtick, after all. So, if you buy something and it doesn’t live up to your expectations, you won’t be as disappointed as you would be if you bought an Away suitcase for double the price and it didn’t perform well. Still, if you want to err on the side of caution, that’s easy! Just stick with our top recs.